Sunday, November 22, 2026

Expelling Immigrants Not Enough to Prevent Survival or Even Growth of Ethnic Enclaves, Shustov Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, Nov. 18 – Russian officials regularly suggest that their increasing expulsion of Central Asians represents a solution to the problem of the formation and growth of ethnic enclaves, but expulsions alone are not enough to protect Russia from that outcome, Aleksandr Shustov says.

            The Russian nationalist commentator says that if Moscow is going to get really serious about doing so, without going back to a system of residence permits like the one that existed in Soviet times, it will be necessary to change two other arrangements  (ritmeurasia.ru/news--2026-11-18--kak-ne-dopustit-pojavlenija-etnicheskih-anklavov-v-rossii-91703).

            On the one hand, Shustov says, Russia must cancel the 1996 agreement that allows Tajiks to take Russian citizenship without giving up their Tajik citizenship, something that guarantees they will continue to move back and forth between the two countries and will live as a group when they are in the Russian Federation.

            And on the other, he argues, rules allowing citizens of Commonwealth of Independent States members to acquire Russian citizenship via the simplified rules governing the return of compatriots will have much the same impact, bringing in people who are culturally and linguistically dissimilar to Russians who will want to live together.

            Taking either of these steps and especially the latter would further fragment the post-Soviet states, alienating many especially in Tajikistan and other Central Asian countries who have gotten used to current arrangements; but unless this is done, Shustov says, what may appear a temporary problem will become permanent, regardless of how many immigrants are expelled.

No comments:

Post a Comment