Paul
Goble
Staunton, December 9 – Russian officials
in the oil-rich Khanty-Mansiisk Autonomous District are moving to suppress a
unique arrangement involving a three-mandate legislative district which was
originally created to ensure that the titular nationalities of that district,
even though they form barely two percent of the total population nonetheless
will be represented.
The regional legislature’s committee
on law and local administration took that decision yesterday and the entire
body is expected to give its approval to the change today, according to the
URA.ru news agency (ura.ru/news/1052233192). This move is
being obscured by a concurrent decision to increase the size of the regional
parliament to 38 seats.
For many, this may seem an
unimportant development, but it is critical for three reasons. First, it
represents yet another step away from arrangements in Russian regions and
republics left over from Soviet times to ensure that minorities are
represented. This “majoritarian” democracy can easily become “totalitarian,”
especially where the courts are gelded as in Russia today.
Second, it is part and parcel of a campaign
by Moscow, regional Russian officials, and Russian business to exclude the
voices of the numerically small peoples of the North and other regions because
such people are often the only ones speaking out against the destruction of the
environment in the name of development and profit.
Over the past several years, Russian
officials have moved to take control of or suppress the organizations of these
peoples and to arrest or at least harass activists on their behalf. Eliminating
their access to elected offices in this way will further isolate and silence
some of Russia’s smallest and most at risk nations.
And third, this action, taken far from
Moscow and thus under the radar screen of many observers, will signal to others
across the Russian Federation that the Putin regime supports freezing out
non-Russians by such measures and thus will encourage officials in the regions
and republics to take more steps in this direction.
That will undoubtedly please some
Russian nationalists who would like to see the Russian Federation become simply
Russia, but it will infuriate many non-Russians and trigger new and possibly
extra-systemic conflicts that the regime will have more difficulty in
controlling that it does when it works with the representatives of these groups
in official structures.
But there is a larger danger as well, one that has been
pointed to by Valery Korovin, a sociologist at Moscow State University and a
member of Russia’s Social Chamber, in a commentary yesterday contrasting the
way in which nationalism might save Europe but could easily destroy Russia (evrazia.org/news/43771).
Korovin says that
many Russians are so intrigued by the idea, widely pedaled by the Kremlin, that
right-wing nationalism of the kind offer by France’s Marine Le Pen, for
example, is the only thing that can save Europe that they have forgotten how
dangerous Russian nationalism can be in the Russian Federation itself.
“If ethnic Russians in Russia
declare that it is necessary to construct an ethnic Russian political nation,
they will be throwing out challenges to all other identities and there are a
multitude of them. Russian civic political identity dissolves all into a
melting pot of a civic political nation, together with the Russian people.”
The response to this, he continues,
is that some Russians want to form “their own ethnic Russian political nation.”
But if they do that, then others will want to do the same. The Tatars, for
example, will say ‘we then will create a Tatar political nation.’ And the
Bashkirs will declare that ‘we too will create a Bashkir political nation.’”
“And the Yakuts will say the same,
and the Chechens will declare that we will create a Chechen Republic of
Ichkeria.” All of that, Korovin says, “will
split apart Russia as a united state” and that means that “nationalism in
Russia where identity is displayed in all its fullness is a threat to the existence
of [that] state.”
No comments:
Post a Comment