Paul
Goble
Staunton, Oct. 28 – In an article
provocatively entitled “A Panikhid for Humanity, Andrey Kolesnikov argues that
since Putin began his expanded war in Ukraine five years ago, Russians have
been part of a memorial service for the passing of everything that makes them fully
human – morality, statehood, and a rejection of independent thinking.
Crying for the deceased, the Russian
commentator says, is where humanity begins because it makes the individual the
center of life and underscores just “how important a single and unique person
is on this side of the grave” (novayagazeta.ru/articles/2026/10/28/panikhida-po-cheloveku).
“Totalitarian systems do not know
the human self, they only know the ‘we’ in which you can dissolve, become invisible
and accept for yourself “the yoke with the rattles yes scourge”. And there is
only one ‘’” that equates itself with the country, the Motherland, the people,
the state, society, and the mass “we” should agree with this only ‘I’ in
everything.”
That is what Stalin achieved and it
is what a small group of intellectual recognized near the end of Soviet times,
Kolesnikov says; now, it is what Putin and his regime have sought to recreate again,
by destroying the central figure of humanity, the individual, and subordinating
him to the mass, opening the way to mass crimes.
In the 20th century, the
most horrific crimes are “mass crimes, those in which not only the victims are
in the millions but the criminal is an organized mass,” he continues. What has
been happening over the last five years is that that approach from which
Russians had begun to turn away is being restored.
Understanding what is going on is the
first step to opposing and overcoming it, he says. “This psychology of
subordination and self-justification in one group of accomplices works on the
example of large communities, it explains everything in the mechanisms of
conformity of the masses, besides protected from the torment of conscience and
shame by distancing from the fact that violence occurs somewhere.”
Kolesnikov continues: “Today, the semi-totalitarian system
has entered a new quality: it has become much more open in demonstrating
brutality: the militant dialect of the central television talk show and the
logic of destroying the enemy have become the language of pro-Kremlin experts
and even state policy.”
“No one will now refute Stalin’s “right”, on
the contrary, state repression is justified by positive historical experience.
It is no longer a legacy of late Soviet, it is the heritage of 1937, 1938, 1949
and other terrible years. Totalitarian practices of subordination and
self-justification are reproduced in an impeccable way.”