Thursday, November 19, 2026

Tallinn Setting Up a Cloud-Based Digital System to Run Estonia if It is Occupied and Set the Stage for Its Ultimate Recovery of Independence

Paul Goble

            Staunton, Nov. 16 – The Estonian government, which in 2007 became the first state subject to a country-wide cyber attack by Moscow, is creating a cloud-based digital system to allow it to govern from abroad in the event of a physical occupation and set the stage for its ultimate and rapid restoration of independence.

            That effort has been described by the US publication, Politico, whose coverage of what Tallinn has done so far is now being picked up by publications in Europe and Russia (politico.eu/article/estonias-digital-preppers-have-a-doomsday-backup-plan/  and readovka.news/news/251967/).

            By basing copies of its computer files abroad and by thinking about what Politico describes as a “doomsday” scenario, Estonia is proceeding as it has since the Russian cyber attack of almost 20 years ago, relying on building computer capability abroad rather than assuming that its security requires it to pull back everything to within its national borders.

            But probably the most important signal this news sends is just how worried Estonians now are about the possibility of a Russian move against them, a move that they intend not only to resist as it happens but to create structures that will allow them to break the occupation and win back the independence they recovered earlier.

            For background on what Estonia has been doing and why other governments in the regions should recognize that Tallinn is showing the way for them, see in particular Joel Burke’s detailed study based on his experience as a former Estonian official, Rebooting a Nation: The Incredible Rise of Estonia, E-Government and the Startup Revolution (London: Hurst, 2025).

50,000 have Fled Badakhshan since 2021 in Response to Deteriorating Economic Situation, Continuing Tajikistan Oppression and Expanding Chinese Presence

Paul Goble

            Staunton, Nov. 16 – Some 50,000 people have fled Tajikistan’s Gorno-Badakhshan Autonomous Oblast, more than 20 percent of that isolated and sparsely populated region bordering Afghanistan and China that nonetheless forms 45 percent of Tajikistan’s total land areas although only two percent of that country’s population, ADC Memorial reports.

            The reasons they have left include a deteriorating economic situation, continuing oppression by the Tajikistan government in Dushanbe, and the rapidly expanding Chinese presence, including military bases, and the aspirations of at least some in Bejing to reclaim the region for China.

            Sources for those conclusions include timesca.com/gorno-badakhshan-faces-a-population-exodus/, en.fergana.agency/news/150747/#google_vignette, windowoneurasia2.blogspot.com/2023/10/china-increasing-its-military-presence.html, windowoneurasia2.blogspot.com/2022/01/new-chinese-base-in-tajikistan-will.html and jamestown.org/beijing-implies-tajikistans-pamir-region-should-be-returned-to-china/.

            This population decline makes it likely that Tajikistan will find it increasingly difficult to defend Badakhshan against penetration by Afghanistan radicals and that China will continue its military and political expansion there to the point that Badakhshan may even become de facto part of China in the neat term and de jure part of it in the future.

            And because that is likely, what happens in Badakhshan as its population continues to decline is guaranteed to cast a shadow over a far larger part of the world than just Tajikistan, although the Tajik state will be threatened in the first instance, much as it was in the 1990s, and will be forced to turn to Russia or even China lest it lose even more.

Soviet Identity Remains in Place and Continues to Shape Russian Thinking, Savvin Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, Nov. 14 – Russians may have turned away from communism but their minds remain shaped by the power of the Soviet identity Moscow imposed on them when the Soviet Union existed, an identity that reflects the compromises the communists made in a largely modernized country on which they imposed totalitarianism, Dmitry Savvin says.

            The editor of the Riga-based conservative Russian Harbin portal discusses how and why this identity was created and why it remains, but perhaps the most important portion of his article is a list of 14 characteristics of this Soviet-er mentality that he argues remains in place (harbin.lv/sovetskaya-identichnost-sverkhkratkiy-ocherk). These include:

1.     “State power is perceived as transcendentally given, an elemental force beyond human influence” with a “sacred” status.

2.     This power is “personified in ‘an ideal hero,’” the founder or current ruler of the country.

3.     “Concepts such ‘the Motherland’” refer exclusively to the state and patriotism is “defined exclusively as loyalty” to the powers that be.

4.     This identity is characterized by “a near-total absence of civic consciousness or civic self-organization” and “a fundamental lack of understanding what these concepts are or why they might be necessary.”

5.     This view is supported by “extreme social atomization which exists alongside a proclaimed ethos of ‘collectivization’ or ‘communalism.’”

6.     Such identities lead the population to expect that the state itself “must be strong and regulate every sphere of social life.”

7.     Those holding this view see private property not as something sacred but something that should and is viewed with suspicion.

8.     “Nationally based culture is completely replaced by mass culture.”.

9.     That is sometimes obscured by the fact that an extreme form of xenophobia is cultivated and expected.

10.  Indifference toward religion is cultivated and combined with “the most primitive superstitions.”

11.  Such identities feature “a low level of ethnic solidarity” and preference for thinking of the country as a whole.

12.  This Soviet survival includes “ignorance and misunderstanding of European political culture” and arrangements like the separation of power.

13.  This ignorance is combined with “a deep knowledge of the true mechanisms of the function of this system which are perceived as normal and even eternal.”

14.  And that combination produces legal nihilism with the only acceptable form of resistance to power is either “corruption” or “self-isolation.”

Monday, November 16, 2026

All Five Countries of Central Asia in Top 16 in the World in Use of Water Per Capita, AQUASTAT Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, Nov. 15 – Aquastat, the United Nations body which monitors world consumption around the world, says that all five of the countries of Central Asia rank in the top 15 in terms of water use per capita, although overwhelmingly this water goes to agriculture or is lost in the aging distribution system.

            Turkmenistan ranks second, Uzbekistan seventh, Kazakhstan tenth, Kyrgyzstan eleventh, and Tajikistan sixteenth, Aquastat says. Azerbaijan which some now group with the Central Asia countries ranks eighth. Almost all of the water used by these countries goes to agriculture or is lost in distribution systems (cronos.asia/news/rashod-vody-na-cheloveka/).

            Among Central Asian countries, Kazakhstan has done the most to reduce the amount of water it uses. Today, it is expending nearly 40 percent less than it did at the time the Kazakhstan became independent in 1991. One reason Kazakhstan has had an easier time doing so is that it uses a lower percentage of water for agriculture – 62 percent – than do the others.

            One reason that Kazakhstan has worked so hard to cut water use is that 44 percent of its water comes from abroad – from China, Uzbekistan, Russia, and Kyrgyzstan – and thus access to water is a question of national security as other countries can restrict the flow of water into Kazakhstan if it does not do what they want.

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Patriotism and Sovereignty Outrank Life and Mercy as Traditional Russian Values, Putin Aide Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, Nov. 13 – Aleksandr Kharichev, head of the Presidential Administration’s office for monitoring and analyzing social processes, says that patriotism and the defense of Russian sovereignty outrank the defense of life and the showing of mercy as traditional Russian values.

            Four years ago, the Kremlin published a laundry list of values it said were “traditionally Russian;” and last week the Duma passed legislation that will make violating those punishable by law (meduza.io/news/2026/11/13/patriotizm-vyshe-zhizni-i-miloserdiya-v-kremle-reshili-sdelat-ierarhicheskuyu-vertikal-dlya-traditsionnyh-tsennostey).

            Now, Kharichev has provided the clearest indication yet that for the Kremlin some values are much more important than others, with those about patriotism and national defense at the top and those concerning the defense of individuals and their rights and the display of mercy far down the list.

            Such a ranking is hardly surprising, but it is important to note because it undercuts the arguments of those who defend the Putin regime regarding traditional Russian values by making it very, very clear that for the Kremlin, it is security of the state rather than the characteristics of Russian people that it is concerned about.

‘To Be Precise’ Says There are Many More Cases of Slavery in Russia Than Moscow Brings Charges Against or Even Investigates

Paul Goble

            Staunton, Nov. 13 – Moscow says that it convicted nine Russians for using slave labor in 2025, a figure about twice that in each of the previous 15 years but one that gives little information about just how much slavery is actually present in the Russian Federation, according to the To Be Precise portal.

            Slavery-like cases, the portal says, are often investigated under other articles of the criminal code because such charges  are easier to investigate and bring to trial” or they are ignored altogether until scandals break out (tochno.st/materials/osudili-za-ispolzovanie-rabskogo-truda-v-rossii-v-2025-godu). Between 220 and 880 cases of slavery “were hidden” under such alternative articles between 2010 and 2024, it estimates.

            Ninety-two percent of these additional cases, To be Precise says, involved sexual exploitation and prostitution. This focus is perhaps understandable, but even it is incomplete: often officials ignore the problem and add the charge of slavery only as a result of media coverage and public outrage.

Moscow City and Not Just the Russian Government Profoundly Affects Development of All Other Federal Subjects, Shirov Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, Nov. 13 – In a paper that has not been published, Aleksandr Shirov, the head of the Institute of National Economic Forecasting of the Russian Academy of Sciences, says that Moscow “directly determines the development of the economy and the financial well-being of the federal subjects.”

            Some of this dominance reflects the fact that it is the seat of the central government but much of it reflects the enormous power of businesses centered in the capital which simultaneously aid and exploit the economies of the federal subjects, Shirov says (http://club-rf.ru/news/65597).

            In many cases, the Russian economic prognosticator says, Moscow is responsible for 40 percent or more of the GDP generated in the regions, to judge from excerpts of his paper that have been published, according to a report by the editors of the experts of the Club of the Regions portal.

            That Moscow is predominant is widely recognized by independent experts, but it is seldom acknowledged so directly by someone like Shirov who is close to the center of power. Indeed, the fact that his paper hasn’t been published in full reflects the judgment of the Kremlin that this is not the kind of information it wants distribute.

            After all, his figure of 40 percent dependence of the federal subjects on Moscow is much higher than many in the regions now think and therefore it is likely that as the numbers in his paper do leak out, it will exacerbate anti-Moscow feelings in many of them, given the economic stringencies the regions are now subject to because of Moscow’s policies.