Staunton, September 3 -- The flood of news stories from a country as large, diverse and strange as the Russian Federation often appears to be is far too large for anyone to keep up with. But there needs to be a way to mark those which can’t be discussed in detail but which are too indicative of broader developments to ignore.
Consequently, Windows on Eurasia each week presents a selection of these other and typically neglected stories at the end of each week. This is the 98th such compilation, and it is again a). double issue with 26 from Russia and 13 from Russia’s neighbors. Even then, it is far from complete, but perhaps one or more of these stories will prove of broader interest.
1. Will ‘a Woman, a Monkey or a Horse’ Run Against Putin Next Year? No one thinks that any opponent could defeat Vladimir Putin in next year’s presidential race, but the Kremlin leader and his regime are concerned about boosting participation which threatens to be quite low given that everyone knows what they outcome will be. Among the strategies being discussed, Moscow observers say, is running “a woman, a monkey and a horse” against him to add interest (newsland.com/community/7973/content/sopernikami-a-na-vyborakh-mogut-stat-zhenshchina-obeziana-porosenok-i-loshad/5978906rosbalt.ru/russia/2017/09/01/1643055.htmlnewsland.com/community/4109/content/russkie-zhivushchie-za-granitsei-protiv-a/5973977 and sueddeutsche.de/politik/thinktank-auslandsrussen-gegen-putin-1.3642479), in part because fact-checking shows he often doesn’t get things right (7x7-journal.ru/item/98163), in part because of increasing repression (newsland.com/community/129/content/avtor-knigi--na-mirovoi-arene-nikolai-zubkov-arestovan-sudom-za-prizyvy-k-ekstremizmu/5978036ura.news/news/1052302881). Meanwhile, for the second year in a row, Putin won’t attend the UN General Assembly meeting in New York (echo.msk.ru/news/2048232-echo.html), and at home, he faces problems protecting his daughter and the daughter of his press secretary from legal harassment (graniru.org/Politics/Russia/President/m.263642.html and newsland.com/community/4765/content/doch-peskova-obvinili-v-oskvernenii-khrama/5971624rusmonitor.com/krug-druzejj-a-suzilsya.html and newsland.com/community/1713/content/ssha-tolkaiut-krupnyi-biznes-rf-na-miatezh-protiv-a/5978060). But if the latter is the case, Washington appears to have failed. According to the Bloomberg news agency, Russia’s billionaires have seen their wealth grow by 17 billion US dollars since the start of this year (novayagazeta.ru/news/2017/09/02/134946-bloomberg-rossiyskie-milliardery-s-nachala-goda-stali-bogache-na-17-mlrd-dollarov).
2. Moscow Calls US Visa Slowdown Act of Genocide. The Russian foreign ministry in its increasingly hyperbolic way accused the US of “genocide” against Russians by its announcement that Russians would face longer wait times to get American visas, an implicit recognition of just how desperate some Russians are to get to the US for medical treatment or other reasons (znak.com/2017-08-28/zaharova_obvinila_ssha_v_genocide_rossiyan_iz_za_zamorozki_vydachi_viz). Moscow said it wouldn’t respond immediately to this mistaken American action, but in fact, it has, increasing its Internet-based attacks on the US since the Charlottesville demonstrations (themoscowtimes.com/news/zakharova-russia-wont-respond-to-us-visa-58778 and bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-09-01/russia-linked-bots-hone-online-attack-plans-for-2018-u-s-vote). Some Russians are upset that they are losing jobs following the Moscow-mandated reduction in US personnel in Russia (politsovet.ru/56400-genkonsulstvo-ssha-v-ekaterinburge-uvolilo-bolshe-poloviny-rossiyskih-sotrudnikov.html), but others are so enthusiastic about the break that they want Moscow to close all US consulates in Russia, including the one in Vladivostok (beregrus.ru/?p=9962newsland.com/community/4765/content/rabotniki-konsulstva-rf-v-san-frantsisko-prosiat-politubezhishche-v-ssha/5979149).
Is the Russian Revolution of 1991 ‘Devouring Its Own’ or Keeping the State a Terrorist Organization? Russian commentaries this week continued their tradition of trying to fit the current Putin regime into earlier Russian models. One pro-communist one suggested that “the criminal feudal revolution of 1991-1993” was now “devouring its own children (forum-msk.org/material/news/13642318.html). Another liberal one argued that Putin’s regime is one in which the powers that be are little more than a terrorist organization (soundcloud.com/yuri-rashkin/slava-rabinovich-v-rossii-net-vlasti-a-est-terroristicheskaya-organizatsiyaregnum.ru/news/polit/2315461.html), with a third saying that it would have been better if Russia had never given up the monarchy (newsland.com/community/4765/content/opros-tret-rossiian-schitaiut-chto-bylo-by-luchshe-esli-by-v-rossii-sokhranilas-monarkhiia/5971783monarhist.info/news/4493ng.ru/editorial/2017-08-29/2_7061_red.html and liberal.ru/articles/7181). Finally, a St. Petersburg historian has called for limited lustration. He says that those who have served in the KGB or FSB should lose their rights to hold political office (news.mail.ru/society/3022262/
4. ehorussia.com/new/node/14737). Perfumes and cosmetics are among the things that have already disappeared (versia.ru/minpromtorg-ozabotilsya-problemoj-importozameshheniya-v-parfyumernoj-i-kosmeticheskoj-promyshlennosti). As ever more Russians face difficulties finding work, Moscow says that the decline in the share of the population at work is a good thing for Russia (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=59A532D38C828). Russians are cutting back on foreign travel and spending less on their children for school supplies (islamsng.com/sng/news/13176 and lenta.ru/news/2017/08/30/wciom/). One intriguing development is that the record grain harvest may lead to record deflation in August (iz.ru/638795/alina-evstigneeva-valentina-dorokhova/rekordnyi-urozhai-zernovykh-nadavit-na-infliatciiu). Other economic news this week includes: one in every three Russians relies on a private garden for food (kp.ru/daily/26726.7/3752214/), ten percent of Russian firms are at the edge of bankruptcy (krizis-kopilka.ru/archives/44341), the number of pensioners working has fallen by five percent this year (polit.ru/article/2017/09/01/hundredword/) despite growing problems with pension funds (ng.ru/omics/2017-08-30/1_7062_pensfond.html), Moscow says that it has identified 51,000 cases of wage arrears in the first half of 2017 (iz.ru/638871/bogdan-stepovoi-angelina-galanina/za-okladom-prishel-rostrud), and public transportation is stopping in some Russian cities because the bus and tram lines haven’t paid their bills (kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/308833/). In adition, there are media reports that Russia’s production of oil is declining (news.rambler.ru/business/37799904-v-rossii-snizilas-dobycha-nefti/).
5. Even Well-Off Russians Don’t See a Future in Russia for Themselves and Their Children. Even those Russians who are middle class or better don’t think that they or their children can expect to have a bright future if they remain in Russia (ura.news/articles/1036271970). In the minds of many, “nothing good” happens in Russia (business-gazeta.ru/article/355613). Moreover, ever more Russians are taking note of the fact that many Russians who were born in the USSR have done far better even spectacularly so after emigrating to the West (newsland.com/community/88/content/rozhdionnye-v-sssr/5978707).
6. 26,300 Russian Schools have Been Closed Since Putin Came to Power. The Russian Federation largely maintained the number of schools that had existed in the RSFSR until Vladimir Putin took office when they began to close, especially in rural areas, in massive numbers (apn-spb.ru/opinions/article26656.htm and nakanune.ru/articles/113220/). In some places, rural schools no longer provide free bus rides for pupils (idelreal.org/a/28694399.html), and some feel that the only thing children will be taught now is that “Crimea is Ours” (fedpress.ru/article/1846939) and that Pavlik Morozov is a model for how children should behave (agonia-ru.com/archives/10986). As a result, Russians are now homeschooling some 100,000 children, a dramatic increase from almost none in 1991 (snob.ru/selected/entry/128385). The situation may soon get worse. Some in the defense ministry want to link every school to a military unit (iz.ru/639751/pavel-panov/voennye-chasti-pridut-v-shkoly).
7. Russians, Raised with Soviet Homogeneity, Find Diversity Daunting. Given the gray monotony of Soviet life when everyone was encouraged to be like everyone else, many Russians find the diversity that has emerged since 1991 a challenge, and this is a major reason they often express distaste at those who are different (thequestion.ru/questions/38072/pochemu-sredi-naseleniya-sovremennoi-rossii-tak-plokho-razvita-lyubogo-vida-tolerantnost). Often, because whole Russian families move to cities, their traditional way of life clashes with the new urban realities (demoscope.ru/weekly/2017/0735/tema04.php and demoscope.ru/weekly/2017/0735/tema08.phpiz.ru/638390/evgenii-deviatiarov/turoperatoram-mogut-dat-1-mlrd-rub-na-razvitie-vnutrennego-turizma).
8. ’90 Percent of Russians Live in Stress; the Remainder Live Abroad.’ That is a line that has been circulating on Russian and Western social media (twitter.com/altword/status/904399846181924866). The deteriorating economic situation is leading to more divorces and fewer marriages and that in turn is pushing down the birthrate in many places (kvnews.ru/news-feed/omskaya-oblast-vhodit-v-troyku-samyh-razvodyashchihsya-regionov-sibiri and ng.ru/economics/2017-08-29/1_7061_brak.html), putting more burdens on the declining number of working-age Russians (charter97.org/ru/news/2017/8/27/261026/). Russians have been warned that the death rate is likely to increase this winter as a result of a flu epidemic (newizv.ru/news/society/29-08-2017/etoy-zimoy-v-rossii-ozhidaetsya-rost-smertnosti-ot-grippa), and Russians with CML leukemia are dying who don’t have to because they cannot obtain the new miracle drugs available in the West (iarex.ru/articles/54449.htmltakiedela.ru/2017/08/takaya-rossiya-semya/).
9. Voynovich Says Tatarstan Can Be an Independent Country. Russian émigré writer Vladimir Voynovich says that the Republic of Tatarstan has everything necessary to become an independent country (charter97.org/ru/news/2017/8/28/261158/). His words have encouraged many Tatars because Moscow commentators believe that their hard line against Kazan has blocked Tatarstan from moving in a Ukrainian direction (ruskline.ru/opp/2017/sentyabr/01/moskva_predotvrawaet_ukrainskij_scenarij_v_tatarstane/nazaccent.ru/content/25228-v-udmurtii-sokratilas-chislennost-besermyan.html), the Khakass and the Bashkirs are working to save their languages in the schools of their republics (nazaccent.ru/content/25223-den-hakasskogo-yazyka-vpervye-otmetyat-v.html and nazaccent.ru/content/25212-vsemirnyj-kurultaj-bashkir-razrabotaet-programmu-po.html), the demographic explosion in the North Caucasus means that the number of children entering schools in that region has risen there more than anywhere else in Russia (kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/308866/), the Maris have complained to the presidential plenipotentiary about their underrepresentation in government structures in their republic (mariuver.com/2017/08/28/polpr-obr/), the Russian Germans mark the anniversary of their deportation (nazaccent.ru/content/25171-rossijskie-nemcy-pochtili-pamyat-deportirovannyh-rodstvennikov.html), officials parachuted into national republics are being forced to come up with a brand suggesting familiarity with the titular nation (afterempire.info/2017/08/29/buy-karelian/), and Vladimir Putin has begun appointing officials at the municipal level who will bear responsibility for the implementation of nationality policy at that level (politsovet.ru/56410-putin-poruchil-naznachit-otvetstvennyh-za-nacionalnye-otnosheniya-v-gorodah.html).
10. One Russian in Four has Never Been to Moscow and Most Don’t Want to Live There. New research shows that a quarter of all Russians have never visited Moscow and that most Russians do not have any desire to live in the city (echo.msk.ru/news/2048200-echo.html and echo.msk.ru/news/2047750-echo.html). An Omsk scholar says what many think: if Moscow would allow the regions to keep the tax money they collect, they wouldn’t need subsidies from the center (newizv.ru/news/society/29-08-2017/professor-kostarev-ostavte-omsku-nalogi-i-nikakaya-stolichnost-nam-ne-nuzhnabusiness-gazeta.ru/article/355943). Meanwhile, there are indications that regionalism is intensifying in many places across the country (afterempire.info/2017/08/27/kamchatka-japan/, ng.ru/politics/2017-08-28/1_7060_kalinngrad.html, afterempire.info/2017/08/30/first-for-siberia/ and afterempire.info/2017/08/30/suvalki/).
11. Could Moscow Make Roman Catholicism a ‘Traditional’ Russian Faith? Some are speculating that the Russian government might decide to add Catholicism to the list of traditional faiths given its growth in many regions and the desire of the Kremlin to ally itself with the Vatican on conservative issues (regnum.ru/news/polit/2314594.html and capost.media/special/obzory/katolicheskiy_kavkaz_istoriya_i_sovremennost_odnoy_iz_samykh_bolshikh_konfessiy_mira_na_yuge_rossii//pravoslavie.ru/105915.html), studies show that Russians do not consider training children on religious issues in schools to be important (politsovet.ru/56379-rossiyane-ne-schitayut-vazhnym-vospityvat-v-detyah-veru-v-boga-i-poslushanie.html), the Moscow Patriarchate has taken up the cudgels for the 70,000 North Korean Christians now in jail there putting the Russian church at odds with the Russian state (rusk.ru/newsdata.php?idar=78812), Orthodox priests using reports on confessions have classified Russians’ sin life (philologist.livejournal.com/9553610.html and interfax-.ru/?act=print&div=20342mariuver.com/2017/09/01/soderzh-hramy/).
12. Moscow has Evacuated Russians Living Near the North Korean Border. As tensions between Pyongyang and the US intensify, Moscow has evacuated Russians living near the Russian-North Korean border (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=59A5427157882). Other stories reflecting domestic concerns about security include reports about spy mania sweeping the country (ru.krymr.com/a/28703011.html), anger in social networks about film of Russians fighting in Syria (fedpress.ru/article/1844972), and spreading incidents of violence across the country (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=59A3FDCE058EA, kasparov.ru/material.php?id=59A3DBD778466, http://politsovet.ru/56436-v-ekaterinburge-neizvestnyy-ustroil-strelbu-vozle-detskogo-sada.html and newsland.com/community/4765/content/v-ufe-vzorvali-byvshego-politseiskogo-kozhevnikova-obviniavshegosia-v-pytkakh/5978068camarade.biz/node/26066),and a Moscow policeman was investigated for organizing a prostitution ring (spektr.press/news/2017/08/28/v-moskve-sotrudnicu-policii-zapodozrili-v-prostitucii/). And ever more Russians complained that Kremlin spending on the Kerch bridge and various foreign adventures were preventing officials from addressing pressing problems at home (ng.ru/regions/2017-08-29/100_kalmykia290817.html and kasparov.ru/material.php?id=59A810453C2C8).
13. Moscow Doesn’t Want Western Observers at Zapad Exercise Lest They See Its Weaknesses, Golts Says. Aleksandr Golts, a leading independent Moscow military analyst, says that the reason Moscow doesn’t want Western observers at exercises like Zapad 2017 is that the Kremlin fears that they will see just how many problems its military is suffering from (golos-ameriki.ru/a/nato-concerned-about-west-2017/4000817.html). Russia was further embarrassed by the crash of one of its planes at an airshow (echo.msk.ru/news/2048268-echo.html ) as well as by reports that many Russian weapons systems have not worked well in Syria (svpressa.ru/war21/article/180093/). Further, it was caught out by Russian sources for understating to the UN its spending on the military by 42 percent (rbc.ru/economics/30/08/2017/59a5a8189a79470f92154521?from=newsfeed) and by German investigations of Russian corruption of German elites (ru.rfi.fr/evropa/20170828-igor-eidman-putin-sozdal-sistemu-korrumpirovaniya-nemetskikh-elit and thechechenpress.com/developments/13771-kak-nemtsy-platyat-za-putinskikh-agentov.html).
14. Ever More Russians Believe They Live in an Unjust Country. Ever more Russians believe that the Russia of Vladimir Putin is an unjust country and a share of them are prepared to protest against that (newsland.com/community/5134/content/v-rossii-narastaet-oshchushchenie-nespravedlivosti-gosudarstvennogo-ustroistva/5971527newsru.com/russia/26aug2017/mosinet.html and ixtc.org/2017/08/v-rossii-proshli-mitingi-za-svobodnyy-internet/ixtc.org/2017/08/v-moskve-zaderzhana-aktivistka-za-plakat-v-pamyat-o-vyhode-na-ploschad-v-1968-godu/), a new debate on whether anyone should be able to use crypto currency in Russia because some see it as a form of political protest (ej.ru/?a=note&id=31504 and chaskor.ru/news/rossijskim_chastnym_litsam_zapretyat_denezhnye_operatsii_s_kriptovalyutoj_42378), a NIMBY protest against a cement factory in Ulyanovsk (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=59A6682B4B47B), extreme Russian nationalist crimes have resulted in four deaths so far this year (sobkorr.ru/news/59A94D90DF56F.html), and residents of Volgograd organized a protest to demand the ouster of that city’s mayor (kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/308830/).
15. Moscow Introduces New Police Vehicle to Combat Mass Demonstrations. Belarusian media are reporting that Russian police have just taken delivery of a special vehicle designed to fight mass demonstrations (by24.org/2017/08/27/new_police_truck_with_codename_shit_for_fighting_against_protesters_presented_in_russia/). Meanwhile, the United Nations called on Moscow to end its practice of declaring publications extremist and keeping them on a list (sova-center.ru/racism-xenophobia/news/counteraction/2017/08/d37761/).
Moscow Gets an Appropriate Monument: to Gun Designer Kalashnikov. Moscow has many statues but none more appropriate is to the designer of the AK-47 (themoscowtimes.com/news/ak-47-designer-kalashnikov-gets-statue-in-moscow-58798). In other parts of the monuments front this week, officials in Chelyabinsk have committed to spending 18 million rubles (300,000 US dollars) to restore a Lenin statue there (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=59A54B559ACD6chelaybinsk), the Northern Fleet has erected a statue to a Russian saint (interfax-religion.ru/?act=news&div=68058), fights over memorials to Admiral Kolchak intensify (kommersant.ru/doc/3398289), the film Mathilda will become a television miniseries in 2019 (ng.ru/news/592882.html), Russians divided on whether they want the names of their relatives who were victims of Stalin on monuments (echo.msk.ru/news/2044656-echo.html, svoboda.org/a/28696654.html and nazaccent.ru/content/25158-v-kazani-ustanovyat-tablichki-s-nazvaniyami.htmlnewsland.com/community/4765/content/v-omske-ustanovili-pamiatnik-tsarskomu-ministru-sergeiu-vitte/5978604
17. UN Body Calls on Russia to Root Out Racism among Football Fans. The UN commission responsible for fighting racism has called on Russia to combat racism among its football fans, even as yet another case of that surfaced in Germany (nazaccent.ru/content/25176-v-oon-prizvali-rossiyu-iskorenit-rasizm.html and newsland.com/community/1039/content/rossiianina-obvinili-v-pokushenii-na-futbolnuiu-komandu-v-germanii/5974077politobzor.net/show-141815-ruki-proch-ot-rf-nhl-postavila-wada-na-mesto-zastupivshis-za-zaripova.htmlnewsland.com/community/4109/content/kak-rossiiu-budut-lishat-olimpiady-chetyre-varianta-razvitiia-sobytii/5977918themoscowtimes.com/news/russia-minister-says-no-chance-winter-games-doping-ban-58771). Further, there were more reports that World Cup stadiums aren’t ready and complaints that officials are destroying historic buildings to prepare for that competition (echo.msk.ru/blog/projectsplash/2045104-echo/, kasparov.ru/material.php?id=599FCD7067FA9 and echo.msk.ru/news/2044656-echo.html).
18. North Korean Dictator Guarded by Former Russian KGB Officers. Tokyo’s Asahi Shimbun reports that North Korea’s Kim Jong Un is guarded by officers who served in the Soviet KGB, a report that raises serious questions given Captain Aleksandr Nikitin’s famous remark that “there are no ex-KGB officers just as there are no ex-german shepherds” (meduza.io/news/2017/08/26/ohranoy-kim-chen-yna-zanyalis-byvshie-agenty-kgb).
19. Putin Cuts Back on Environmental Inspections. Russian media have trumpeted the fact that the number of Russians charged with environmental crimes has fallen by more than 80 percent over the last seven years. But this decline has more to do with a significant cutback in enforcement efforts over that period rather than any improvement in the behavior of Russian companies and officials (newsland.com/community/8090/content/kolichestvo-ekologicheskikh-prestuplenii-v-rf-umenshilos-vdvoe-za-sem-l/5971773 and ecoportal.su/news.php?id=93781).
20. Soviet ‘Detroit’ Dies in Sea of ‘Sex, Drugs, and Cheap Alcohol.’ The city of Tavda in Sverdlovsk oblast, once known as “the Soviet Detroit,” is dying with its population taking refuge in the only things still left to it: “sex, drugs, and cheap alcohol” (theins.ru/obshestvo/68672).
21. Children of Immigrants Account for All the Increase in New Pupils in Russia. Moscow officials have celebrated an increase in the number of children entering school this year, but a close analysis shows that all of the increase came from children of immigrant workers from Central Asia and the Caucasus rather than from children of indigenous ethnic Russians (burckina-new.livejournal.com/802248.html).
22. Chinese Tourists Flood into Russia to Visit 1917 Revolution Sites. The centenary of the Bolshevik revolution is attracting thousands of Chinese tourists into Russia (asiarussia.ru/articles/17472/http://babr24.com/baik/?IDE=164281). And some Russian commentators warn that there are now so many Chinese in the Far East that Beijing could invoke Putin’s Crimean strategy to take the Russian Far East and parts of Siberia whenever it wants (charter97.org/ru/news/2017/9/1/261601/).
23. Rural Doctors and Teachers Rely to Internet to Keep Their Sanity. Newly-minted doctors and teachers who are given supplementary pay to work in rural portions of the Russian Federation say that the only thing that keeps them sane is the availability of Internet connectivity (snob.ru/selected/entry/128391).
24. Internet Growth Forces Moscow TV to Respond by Changing Programming. The clearest indication that the Internet is now a power in Russia is that central Russian television channels are changing their programming to respond to and even correspond with Internet media outlets, something the television networks earlier had been reluctant to do (edpress.ru/news/77/policy/1847312).
25. Communists Picking Up Support from Disappointed Young. Young Russians, upset both by the closure of social lifts and the absence of social justice in their country, are turning to the KPRF and other communist groups, some observers suggest (rosbalt.ru/russia/2017/09/01/1643099.html).
26. Fulfilling the Plan: Road Built Right Through a House in Novosibirsk Oblast. The plan must be fulfilled, whatever the obstacles, at least among highway builders in Novosibirsk. There, the road builders simply destroyed half a house to put a road through without telling the absent residents who, on their return, discovered that they needed to set up a tent to have a place to sleep now that their house has been wrecked (amarok-man.livejournal.com/2431281.html#t33410353).
And 13 more from countries in Russia’s neighborhood:
1. More Bad News from ‘Big’ and ‘Little’ Zones in Russian-Occupied Crimea. Russian occupiers are using electroshocks to torture prisoners in Crimea (ixtc.org/2017/08/pravozaschitniki-zaderzhannyh-krymskih-tatar-pytali-tokom/sobkorr.ru/news/59A428A255E3C.html).
Ever Fewer Russian Tourists Coming to Crimea. Moscow had expected that Russians would flock to Crimea and boost the economy there, but this year, tour operators say, visits to the Ukrainian peninsula are down 20 percent from the already low levels of a year ago (politsovet.ru/56374-turpotok-v-krym-upal-na-20.html
4. Belarusians Demand KGB Archives be Opened. Hundreds of Belarusians staged a demonstration to demand that Minsk allow them access to the archives of the Soviet-era KGB so that they can learn the fate of their relatives under Stalin and other Soviet leaders (charter97.org/ru/news/2017/8/27/261021/).
5. Radio Free Europe Opens New Belarusian Broadcast Facility in Lithuania. Radio Free Europe has opened a new broadcasting facility in Lithuania to beam Belarusian language programming into Belarus (camarade.biz/node/26069). In another linguistic development, the Moscow Patriarchate church in Minsk has released its first ever translation into Belarusian of the New Testament. There are already about a dozen others in circulation (charter97.org/ru/news/2017/9/1/261598/).
Moldova Deports Russian General. The Moldovan authorities blocked the entrance of a Russian general who was planning to visit the breakaway republic of Transdniestria (
8. If Kazakhstan Doesn’t Federalize, It Will Suffer Fate of Ukraine, Russian Warns. A Russian commentator says that if Astana does not federalize Kazakhstan and give Russian areas autonomy, that country will suffer the fate of Ukraine, a reminder if one is needed that demands for federalization of countries neighboring Russia are a form of aggression in and of themselves (cont.ws/@grigmironov/695301).
Kazakhstan May Introduce Criminal Penalties for Offending Feelings of Atheists. Astana is contemplating taking the logical next step in laws about offending others. Officials there are considering introducing fines for those who offend atheists (novayagazeta.ru/news/2017/08/24/134698-vlasti-kazahstana-predlozhili-shtrafovat-za-oskorblenie-chuvstv-ateistov
10. fergananews.com/news/26805 and dw.com/ru /год-без-каримова-что-в-узбекистане-изменилось-при-новом-лидере/a-40331932).
11. Tashkent Fears Cellphones Will Allow Uzbeks to Photograph Things They Shouldn’t. Officials in the Uzbekistan capital are concerned that the spread of cellphones throughout the population could restrict the government’s operations because people will be able to use them to photograph actions that the authorities would prefer to keep hidden (centrasia.ru/news.php?st=1504083060).
12. Tashkent, Bishkek Find Agreement on Borders Easy, on Enclaves Not So Much. Uzbekistan and Kyrgyzstan have made rapid progress on resolving their border dispute in the months since the death of Islam Karimov. They have not made much progress, however, on the far more difficult issue of what to do with the Uzbek enclaves within Kyrgyzstan. Failure to support Uzbeks there will offend not only those people but many Uzbeks in Uzbekistan (ng.ru/cis/2017-08-28/5_7061_tashkent.html).
13. Tajikistan has Highest Birthrate and Only Family Planning Effort in Central Asia. Tajikistan continues to have the highest birthrate of any of the post-Soviet Central Asian countries and thus it is perhaps not surprising that it is the only state there actively promoting family planning measures (caa-network.org/archives/10141).