Paul
Goble
Staunton, September 14 – The
Internet is transforming Circassians both in the North Caucasus homeland where
it is helping ever more of its members to insist on their identity as
Circassians in the upcoming census and in the diaspora where it is bringing together
many who had little contact before.
Both of these developments are
welcome, Circassian activist Andzor Kabard says; but they raise challenges
which no other national group has ever had to deal. The Circassians are
currently being forced to “act in terra incognita given that they simply do not
have any model to copy” (natpressru.info/index.php?newsid=12138).
“Neither the Jewish, nor the
Armenian, nor the Irish, nor the Tibetan or any other experience can serve as a
direct model,” he says, although the Circassians can learn from all of them.
But the Internet has changed the situation dramatically and the Circassian
miracle to use Adel Bashqawi’s term is an Internet-driven one.
Within the borders of the Russian
Federation, the campaign to have Circassians declare their common identity in
the census, now scheduled for early next year, forces them to confront the reality
that in contrast to the situation with other nations, calling oneself a
Circassian in the Russian Federation is invariably “a political act.”
As a result, the act of identifying
not as a Kabard or a Shapsug or one of the other subgroups Moscow has promoted
as the proper identity forces those who take this step into politics, something
that members of other ethnic groups have generally been able to avoid having to
do.
That in turn means that the
Circassians, as they promote this identity and confront Russian opposition –
see windowoneurasia2.blogspot.com/2019/12/circassian-drive-to-declare-common.html
and windowoneurasia2.blogspot.com/2019/12/moscow-worried-about-circassian-drive.html
– must confront political issues they have previously avoided.
Those include not only issues of the
return to the homeland of members of the diaspora who want to come back but
also the formation of a common Circassian republic uniting all the Circassians
historically and, as a result of the Internet, newly minted.
Beyond the borders of the Russian
Federation where 90 percent of the world’s Circassians now live as a result of
the Russian expulsion of the nation in 1864, the Internet has had an even more
complicated set of consequences. It has brought people together who had not
previously worked with one another.
That has simultaneously reopened
issues that many assumed were closed, dividing some existing organizations and
sparking demands for new ones, and leading to the need for the elaboration of a
broader agenda that as many of the Circassians abroad and at home can identify
with and support. Doing this will be anything but easy.
No comments:
Post a Comment