Thursday, August 3, 2017

Putin hasn’t Destroyed Russia but Rather Russia has Destroyed Him, Konchalovsky Says



Paul Goble

            Staunton, August 3 – Many people accuse Vladimir Putin of destroying Russia, film director Andrey Konchalovsky says; but instead “Russia has destroyed Putin” because like any Russian ruler, he finds it hard “rule a state whose population has no idea about democracy … and by according to inviolable tradition voluntarily delegates all power to one single individual.”

            In a wide-ranging interview to Germany’s Spiegel magazine,  the noted film director says that Putin began with a “pro-Western” orientation but has been forced by the nature of the Russian people to become like his predecessors (magazin.spiegel.de/SP/2017/30/152270478/; in Russian at philologist.livejournal.com/9493875.html).

What people need to understand, Konchalovsky says, is that Russians are “an archaic nation, the majority of its people live in the stone age even though they use i-phones. And as far as [its] system of values compared to Europe, [Russians] are in the 11th or 12th centuries when there was no bourgeoisie and no citizens. Marx wrong about this.” 

Russians “never had property,” he points out, “and when an individual does not have anything that he must defend or can sell, he cannot understand what a market economy is. As a result, many Russians cannot understand Germans and Germans, Russians: there exist different systems of priorities” and in fact a clash of “two civilizations.” 
           
 And there is an additional problem: “Russian thought is Manichean: there is only light and darkness, black or white. And that is one of the reasons for the crisis-like development of our society. Dialogue between the left and the right in Russia will never lead to reconciliation or agreement.”

            Asked about his recent film, “The White Nights of Postman Aleksey Tryapitsyn,” Konchalovsky says that he doesn’t view it as denigrating Russia in any way. Instead, the film “simply shows the life of people whom [he] loves and who however strange this may seem don’t suffer.”

Such people can’t be harmed by Western sanctions, he says. “They have lived their entire life under sanctions. They don’t run off in search of French camembert because it has suddenly disappeared from the shelves of stores.” Instead, their response will be to become more patriotic, and if a war begins, they will rally round the Kremlin.

“But when there is no war,” Konchalovsky continues, “then the national idea will disappear into thin air.” 

            Asked to explain his statement that in Russia, “everything is possible except reforms,” the director says that he “had in mind successful reforms. We still haven’t cracked the Russian cultural code … the German one is more understandable than [the Russian].”  That is because the Russian is “a peasant” while the German “from birth” is either a rural resident or a bourgeois.” 

            Compared to the bourgeois, “the peasant has completely different qualities: he is always hostile to the state because it constantly wants to take something from him. The West isn’t in a position to understand this: The CIA in the 1990s thought that the situation would lead to revolts of the hungry.”  That was “complete nonsense,” the director says.

            “In Russia, there cannot be any revolts of the hungry because Russians are always prepared for hunger. Their patience is so great that they can survive injustice.” And that sets them apart from the West. This is “a conflict of two civilizations” and between “such different worlds, there will always be hostility.” The current round, he says, is the West’s fault.

            “The Western man will always be afraid of the Russian,” Konchalovsky says, “even if there is nothing in him to fear. But then he will drink vodka with him and everything will be fine.”

Six Characteristics Define Today’s Stalinists and Explain Why Their Influence is So Large, Pavlova Says



Paul Goble

            Staunton, August 3 – “Stalinist,” like many epithets, is not so much an explanation as something that needs to be explained, US-based Russian historian Irina Pavlova says; and in a new post, she argues that Stalinists are best understood as people who share five particular and interrelated beliefs (ivpavlova.blogspot.com/2017/08/blog-post.html#more).

            First of all, she says, a Stalinist is someone who supports traditional Russian statehood and great power.  Indeed, “the basis of Stalinism lies Russian state traditions …as embodied in the rule of Ivan the Terrible.” During more liberal periods in Russian history, these ideas have receded into the background somewhat, but they have never disappeared.

            “With Stalin, [these views] reached their logical end point,” with the state viewing itself as surrounded by enemies and having as its domestic task the establishment of tight control over the population so that the country will not fall apart and as its foreign ones increasing its influence and power and showing Russia to be a great power.

            That means, Pavlova says, that “the state in Russia is not the civil service [as is the case in other countries] but [an independent] demiurge-power. Power itself is the highest value, it is always primary and the people are always secondary, even though formally the Stalinist declares the Russian multi-national people as the source of all power.”

            Second, Pavlova continues, “a Stalinist is a supporter of ethnic Russian state nationalism. The ideal of the Stalinist is only a centralized and unitary state … [and] in this Russian picture of the world, federation as a system of government organization is alien both to the supreme power and to public consciousness,” whatever the country is called.

            That view is widely shared in the population and even among “various representatives of the so-called elite and anti-Putin opposition,” the historian points out. Indeed, among both systemic liberals and nationalists, “the majority are supporters of the great power position and imperialists.”

            Third, she says, “a Stalinist is a supporter of government ownership and control not only of natural resources but of industry and also of the active interference of the state in the development of science, culture, the social sphere and health care.” Often Stalinists criticize Putin for failing to carrying out “a new industrialization of the country.”

            Fourth, “a Stalinist is a supporter of the development of military industry which in his language is always called not military but defense. In reality, the purpose of this industry is entirely different: not defense against an external enemy but the affirmation of the status of Russia as a great power in the world by force of arms and the militarization of his own country.”

            Fifth, a Stalinist is someone whose consciousness is opposed to law. “He may call for ‘the dictatorship of law,’ but the orders of the supreme power, as a rule, secret are for him always ‘higher than formal legality,’” and he is quite prepared to use “illegal methods” against corruption or other ills.

            And sixth, “a Stalinist is a supporter of social projects introduced ‘from above,’ be  it socialism, democracy or a legal state.” Thus, “calls to ‘build socialism in one country’” are for a Stalinist equivalent to “calls to ‘build a democratic legal state.’ In any case, this means actions ‘from above,’” and that inevitably involves “force and repressions.”

Wednesday, August 2, 2017

On Eve of Zapad 2017 Exercise, Lukashenka Names Belarusian Military Inspection Head


Paul Goble

            Staunton, August 2 – Yesterday, President Alyaksandr Lukashenka replaced the chief of the inspectorate of the Belarusian Armed Forces, the individual who is charged with ensuring that orders from the president are carried out by the country’s military – an especially important post as the beginning of the joint Russian-Belarusian Zapad 2017 exercises approaches. 

            The appointment of Colonel Ivan Boguslavsky was announced yesterday by the Belarusian state news agency. Earlier, he had been acting head of this inspectorate but his appointment gives him significantly more authority in dealing with commanders (belta.by/president/view/boguslavskij-naznachen-nachalnikom-glavnoj-voennoj-inspektsii-vooruzhennyh-sil-belarusi-259745-2017/).

            In its commentary on this development, the Charter 97 portal notes that “the chief military inspectorate of the Armed Forces of Belarus was founded 25 years ago” and is particularly charged with ensuring that all Lukashenka orders are carried out (charter97.org/ru/news/2017/8/2/258386/).

            Making this appointment now may give the Belarusian leader a better handle on the situation as the exercises go forward.