Friday, August 4, 2017

West Backed Forest Brothers in Baltic Countries, Newly Declassified CIA Documents Show



Paul Goble

            Staunton, August 4 – Many in the Baltic countries and elsewhere still celebrate the US non-recognition policy which specified that Washington would never recognize Stalin’s “forcible incorporation” of the three Baltic states into the USSR, a policy that send a clear message to Estonians, Latvians, and Lithuanians that they were not alone in their fight for freedom.

            But at the same time, some of them have asked over the years why the US did not do more to support the Baltic peoples and their aspirations -- even though US policy did not ever promise to take any actions to liberate the three occupied countries, a point Washington was consistent about from 1940 to 1991.

            In fact, however, as some newly declassified CIA documents show, the US government not only carefully kept track of “the forest brothers,” as the underground armed resistance to Soviet power there in the late 1940s and early 1950s was known, but provided some limited covert assistance to these groups.

            Portions of these documents are being published in Russian translation by the Russian staff of the unified news portal of Latvian Radio and Latvian television.  Two selections have been issued (rus.lsm.lv/statja/novosti/obschestvo/taynie-arhivi-tsru.-latviyskie-lesnie-bratja-vozniknovenie-organizacija-kontrol.a244834/ and rus.lsm.lv/statja/novosti/obschestvo/taynie-arhivi-tsru.-latviyskie-lesnie-bratja.-pomosch-zapada.a245141/), and more are promised.

            Like the NATO film released about the forest brothers a month ago, these documents have attracted Moscow’s attention. One commentary by Sergey Orlov of Svobodnaya pressa posted online yesterday directly states that with these documents, “the US has acknowledged its role in the support of ‘the [Baltic] forest brothers’” (svpressa.ru/politic/article/178280/).

            In Orlov’s words, the documents show that “the CIA provided the anti-Soviet underground in the Baltic countries organizational and financial help … and from this it follows in particular,” he continues, “that in August 1950, the CIA approved the financing of ‘the forest brothers.’”

            “The total sum is not clear,” the Svobodnaya pressa writer says, “but in 1953, 134,950 dollars was devoted to one of the projects for assistance to the anti-Soviet underground. Money was also allocated to the support of anti-Soviet Baltic media beyond the borders of the USSR, he organization of a unity conference in the US, and other goals.”

            Orlov does not suggest that the US provided the forest brothers with lethal aid, something he would surely have done if there was anything in the documents to suggest that.  But what he does say about the documents may be far more important to an understanding of the complex picture of life in Soviet-occupied Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania at that time.

            First, he makes it clear that the Central Intelligence Agency was extremely well-informed about the nature and composition of the forest brothers. Second, Orlov’s selective quotations indicate that Washington was extremely cautious in taking any steps that might inflame the situation and cause Moscow to crack down even harder than it already was at that time.

            And third, Orlov mentions that the Americans were not the only people fishing in these troubled waters at the time.  He notes that Stalin’s secret police chief Lavrenty Beriya tried to reach an agreement of some kind with a leader of the anti-Soviet underground in Lithuania whom the NKVD had arrested.

            What the two discussed is “unknown,” the commentator says; but after Beria was arrested, interrogated and then shot in 1953, this Lithuanian, Jonas-Vytautas Zemaitis, was shot in Moscow’s Butyrka prison on November 26, 1954, on the basis of a decision by the Supreme Court of the Lithuanian SSR.

            Zemaitis is now considered a hero in Lithuania, and there is a monument to him at the Lithuanian defense ministry, Orlov says. But that raises a bigger question: is Orlov’s article really about events of almost 70 years ago, or is it really about the present-day agenda of Moscow which remains interested in destabilizing the situation there.

If the latter – and there is every reason to suspect that – this conclusion suggests Moscow will use the further release and translation of US documents as the occasion not only to try to blacken the reputation of the Americans but also to talk about contacts between Baltic leaders in the past and the Soviet secret services in order to sow discord in the three countries.


Thursday, August 3, 2017

Clash Between Tuvin and Ethnic Russian Soldiers at Training Academy Turns Violent



Paul Goble

            Staunton, August 3 – Sixty ethnic Tuvin professional soldiers clashed with about 100 ethnic Russian professional soldiers at a sergeants training academy in Yelan in Sverdlovsk oblast earlier this week. The fighting turned violent and 14 of the soldiers remain hospitalized, according to regional news agencies (ura.news/news/1052299414).

            According to anonymous inside sources, “three months ago approximately 60 contract soldiers arrived from Tuva to take courses” so that they could be promoted. On the night before graduation, they purchased alcohol to celebrate but “having gotten drunk, they recalled” the hostility and mistreatment they had encountered from the ethnic Russian soldiers.

            Armed with knives and clubs, they threw themselves on the Russians, wounding 13 soldiers and one officer. An investigation has begun, and the defense ministry is supposedly flying in from Moscow. But officials have gone out of their say to say that no guns were used in the clash (nakanune.ru/news/2017/8/3/22478334/).

            On the one hand, many may be tempted to dismiss this as the result of alcohol at a time of graduation ceremonies; but on the other, this event may be far more serious than the usual incidents of “dedovshchina” that are routinely reported which involve what the Russians calls “non-standard behavior” by one group of soldiers against others, usually more junior draftees.

            There are at least three reasons for the conclusion, one that will be most worrisome to Russian commanders. First, these were all professional soldiers, people who had been screened for longterm service as sergeants in the Russian army. If they are so deeply split ethnically as to come to blow, unit cohesion below them is likely to be even more problematic.

            Second, the relative size of the two components – 60 Tuvins to 100 ethnic Russians – reflects the demographic decline of the Russian nation and the fact that Moscow is increasingly forced to draft or recruit as professionals ever more non-Russians who continue to grow at a more rapid rate than do the Russians.

            And third, the fact that it was the Tuvans in this case is likely to be worrisome not only because Russian commanders have typically viewed the Tuvans as more loyal and obedient than the North Caucasians whom it still does not draft heavily or promote but have chosen to promote them. 

If Moscow can no longer count on non-Russian nations like the Tuvins, it can’t count on almost anyone other than ethnic Russians. There will thus be fallout from this clash, but it remains to be seen how much of it will be reported. 

Nothing Lasts Forever Whatever the Kremlin Says, Novoprudsky Argues



Paul Goble

            Staunton, August 3 – The Russian authorities have long promoted the idea that whatever is is forever as “an effective means of convincing people that the powers that be are always right” and that it is impossible and even dangerous to try to change anything, according to Gazeta journalist Semyon Novoprudsky.

            In an essay published today, the journalist says that he calls this “the syndrome of ‘imaginary eternity’” and sees evidence of this all the time. When the US introduced sanctions or Russian introduced counter-sanctions, the Kremlin described all of these things as “’forever’” even when it should have been obvious that they had a beginning, a middle and an end (gazeta.ru/comments/column/novoprudsky/10815265.shtml).

            And that propagandistic argument has created an atmosphere for statements equally untrue, Novoprudsky says,  that “’relations of Russia and the West were NEVER good’” and that “’in Russia there will NEVER be reforms of changes for the better.’”  But the idea is not new: in Soviet times, the regime claimed the republics would always be together.

In fact, the Gazeta journalist points out, this “’forever’” lasted less than 69 years, about the length of a single human life time. And none of its leaders from first to last managed that even though their spokespeople insisted that each of them was forever and irreplaceable as well.

Despite the regime’s claims, “nothing is eternal under the moon, and therefore ‘nevers” and ‘forevers’ do not exist in politics. The borders of states and even the states themselves are not eternal. Nor are the longest-ruling leaders eternal” however much they seek to convince their populations otherwise.

“The syndrome of ‘imaginary eternity’ in general is entirely understandable,” he continues. “Its parents are the brevity of an individual human life and the fear of (sometimes on the contrary the desire for) change.” But understanding where it comes from does not make it any less dangerous even if it often is unnoticed, Novoprudsky says.

That is because it is “a powerful weapon of manipulation” for the elites who use it to control their populations. “Its main message is that ‘the future is impossible.’ Everything will always be as it is now.  There is only a great past and the only correct present that directly follows it. And if you try to change something, things will only be worse.”

But where people try or not, “changes all the same are inevitable.”  And as a result, “the syndrome of ‘imaginary eternity’ is the main enemy of normal development” because it suggests that people should not try to act but rather accept the system others have imposed and the future such as it is that these others project.

With the help of this syndrome, he continues, “the authorities are really trying to stop time, to paralyze the will of the nation to changes and development. ‘Sanctions are forever.’ ‘They will always hate us.’ ‘The West is the eternal enemy.’” – all these are attempts to stop time where it is now rather than be open to change or even to the possibility of working for change.

“In reality,” Novoprudsky says, “today was never exactly like yesterday and tomorrow will not be exactly like today. Ideas, the environment, and people all change. Denying that may help some people to live, to cope with what they do not believe they can change or should try to change.

The future will be different, but here is “one additional important detail,” the journalist concludes, “no one says that other times will necessarily be better.”