Thursday, April 29, 2021

Having Retreated into ‘a Closed Conspiratorial World,’ Kremlin Feels Obliged to Crush Any Independence before It Threatens Regime, Shelin Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 27 – In what Sergey Shelin describes as an unprecedented development, the leaders of Russia today have withdrawn “into a closed conspiratorial world” in which they assess all actions, however innocent, as the first steps toward a color revolution to overthrow the regime and thus feel compelled to crush it before that happens.

As a result of this paranoid fear, the Rosbalt commentator says, the powers that be lash out at anyone who seems at all a potential threat and do not feel any need to define not only a picture of a desirable future but even “an image of a desired present, something that results in ever more irrational repression (rosbalt.ru/blogs/2021/04/27/1899495.html).

Because the Russian people know the consequences of acting independently, they become ever more obedient; but instead of that satisfying the men in the Kremlin, it leads the Putin regime to “scrutinize the population ever more closely” and to find threats where none exist in order to create a situation where no one’s behavior can guarantee any personal safety.

Not surprisingly, the Putin regime particularly dislikes the intelligentsia and young people because it sees in their searching and independence of mind a threat. Hence the regime’s new law restricting “enlightenment activity,” a measure whose provisions surpass all the fears critics of the Kremlin had made in the past.

These provisions reflect Putin’s conviction that as he put it, “the actual goals of their [the opposition] is the creation of conditions for changing the foundations of the constitutional system, including via the use of color revolution scenarios.” Now, such people are throwing bottles and stones, but soon they will do worse. And they must be stopped before they can.

“I have no doubt that Vladimir Putin sees reality exactly as he has said,” Shelin continues. Otherwise, what he has been doing makes no sense at all. For him, today’s peaceful protests open the way to shooting and then to a color revolution. For him, scholarly contacts with foreigners are about espionage because that it what such contacts must lead to, in his mind.

But by treating people in this way and openly acknowledging his own logic, Putin is creating an increasingly unstable situation, one in which ever more people can see precisely what he is about and in which at least some will be compelled to conclude that such madness must not be allowed to continue.   

Kremlin’s Shift from Mass Brutality to Targeted Repression a Victory for the Opposition, Gallyamov Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 27 – The Putin regime remains just as committed as ever to the use of repression against its opponents, Abbas Gallyamov says; but it has made a significant tactical change in recent days, ending the mass brutality it employed earlier and using targeted repression instead.

            That change, the former Putin speechwriter argues, represents a step forward as far as the opposition is concerned because the Russian authorities are “very conservative” and don’t like to make any change. But recent events and the reaction of Russians to them have forced it to do so (echo.msk.ru/blog/gallyamov_a/2828900-echo/).

            Several years ago, at a time when Putin’s rating was high, most Russians viewed dissenters as beyond their understanding, Gallyamov continues. But now that has changed. Many in the population and even in the elites don’t like what they see even if many of them for a time remain loyal because they don’t see any alternative to Putin.

            “But even these loyalists are showing ever more dissatisfaction with the current course,” he says. That is because they share many of the concerns that those who have taken to the streets are acting upon. And that means that the use of force against protesters “in this situation” ceases to please people. Instead, it angers them.” And that isn’t something the Putin regime wants.

            According to Gallyamov, the Kremlin is quite capable of using poll results and it cannot have failed to notice this shift. “Therefore, it has been forced to change its approach. Targeted repressions are much better than the use of force in the streets in the sense that they are not as visible.”

            Even if each case is reported on the Internet, this does not have the impact of a single image of mass use of force. And the Kremlin has to be concerned about not only the population given the upcoming Duma elections – ignoring them now would be political suicide -- but also the attitudes of the Russian Guard, many of whose members share the views of the protesters.

            The situation of the Russian opposition today is anything but easy, Gallyamov concludes. “But in one thing it can be calm about. The fact that the powers have been forced to change tactics testified above all that in the struggle for public opinion, the opponents of the regime have achieved significant progress.”

            So significant, that the powers have had to take note of it and change how they are behaving.

Beijing’s ‘Polar Silk Road’ Helping Russia Now But will Allow China to Dominate Northern Route Later, Volgayev Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 27 – China’s ambitious icebreaker construction program and its plans to build Chinese docks in five ports in the Arctic may help Russia develop its Northern Sea Route in the short term but create the possibility that China may either come to dominate that Russian route or even allow Beijing to open its own route there, Vladimir Volgayev says.

            The military analyst for Sovershenno Sekretno provides details on the rapid expansion of China’s northern fleet, with two modern icebreakers of its own design, a third on the way, and other support vessels coming into service, and its plans for building Chinese docks at Murmansk, Sabetta, Arkhangelsk, Tiksi, and Uzden (sovsekretno.ru/articles/polyarnyy-shelkovyy-put/).

            Up to now, Volgayev says, China has relied on Russia for icebreaker support and port facilities, and its own efforts are still helping Moscow reach its ambitious trade goals for the Northern Sea Route. But it is already clear, he suggests, that China is not interested in playing second fiddle to anyone in this area and may soon challenge Russia’s dominance there.

            One indication of China’s expansive intentions was its response to American suggestions that it cooperate with Washington against Moscow in the Northern Sea Route. Beijing has rejected such ideas out of hand, not because it is committed to Russian dominance but because it doesn’t feel it will need to depend on the US which currently has only one icebreaker in service.

            Beijing’s expanding interest in the Northern Sea Route, the analyst says, reflects not only cost calculations but also the belief that Russian military infrastructure along that waterway has already made it safer than using the Suez Canal which is surrounded by increasingly unstable countries.

            But the Chinese leadership is also interested in the route and eventual dominance of it because of another calculation. Russia uses the route almost exclusively for the shipment of bulk cargos of raw materials. The Chinese believe that the future will be dominated by container traffic and that they, not the Russians, will be in a position to dominate that flow.

            All this leaves Moscow in a difficult position. On the one hand, it needs Chinese investment to achieve its own goals along the Northern Sea Route; but on the other, it and other world powers as well can easily see that Chinese goals are larger than the ones that Moscow would like them to be, ultimately if not now a security challenge.  

Putin Now Targeting Social Groups He Earlier had Left Largely Alone, Skobov Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 27 – Yet another mark of Vladimir Putin’s move from authoritarianism to totalitarianism, Aleksandr Skobov says, is that he is now seeking to crush those “niches of free thought” which had existed in Russia up to now and are of the kind that “authoritarian regimes typically allow” (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=6087FD01C1A26).

            The Kremlin leader in recent months has been moving against journalists and bloggers whose activities he had earlier left largely alone. Indeed, one can say, the Moscow commentator continues, that Putin is now targeting “not only activists of opposition organizations such as Open Russia or Navalny’s staff but also representatives of the cultural elite.”

            These include “well-known scholars, instructors and writers” who are typically associated less with political actions than academic seminars. “Often their civic activity is limited to more or less episodic expressions of support in ‘the information space.’ Until now, [the regime] tried specially not to touch them.” Now that has changed.

            And as a result, the risks for members of these groups have gone up as well. If earlier the expression of opposition views could hurt them professionally, now it could not only cost them their jobs but land them behind bars. The Kremlin assumes that in Russia now, those who can’t be intimidated in this way are not more numerous than was the case in Soviet times.

            With each passing month, the Putin regime is more unwilling to accept any “form of legal opposition, even of the legal kind. Indeed, “the ideal of the Putin ruling class is Continental China, which combines a market economy and the opportunity of personal enrichment with a purely totalitarian political regime of the Soviet time.”

            It is precisely in this direction that Putin is taking Russia to a place that is best described as fascism, Skobov suggests. In such a system, no islands of freedom are to be tolerated; and Putin is doing what he can to make sure they won’t be able to exist.

 

Moscow Says Hacking of Russian Medical Labs Way Up This Year, a Sign of International Recognition of Their Success

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 27 – Russian computer experts say that the number of cyberattacks on Russian medical laboratories involved in developing vaccines has risen by 400 percent this year over last, a sign, they suggest, of international recognition of the success Russian labs have had in comparison with those abroad (regnum.ru/news/society/3250801.html).

            Today, Russian officials reported registering 8053 new cases of infection and 392 new deaths from the coronavirus as the pandemic, while plateauing for the country as a whole, ebbed and flowed in various regions (t.me/COVID2019_official/2848 and regnum.ru/news/society/3250801.html).

            Some places are increasing restrictions in advance of the extended May holidays. Ivanovo, for example, will impose entry restrictions during that period to prevent people from elsewhere in Russia bringing the coronavirus with them (ivanovoobl.ru/?type=news&id=36173). And Moscow has told Russians not to buy tickets for travel to Turkey after June 1 (regnum.ru/news/3254525.html).

            On the vaccine front, Deputy Prime Minsiter Tatyana Golikova said Russia has produced 28 million doses of its vaccines and released 17.4 million of them for use in the population at large (regnum.ru/news/3254489.html). She criticized the regions for failing to maintain restrictions or even sign contracts to purchase the vaccine (regnum.ru/news/3254756.html and regnum.ru/news/3254530.html).

            A leading epidemiologist said Russia must increase the rate of vaccinations by a factor of five if it is to have any hope of achieving herd immunity, as evidence is coming in that rates of vaccination are slowing in some cities and even in the Russian military (regnum.ru/news/3254597.html,  regnum.ru/news/3255061.html  and regnum.ru/news/society/3250801.html).

            Some regions, including Magadan and Chukotka are introducing cash prizes for those who do get their shots in hopes of boosting demand for the coronavirus vaccination (interfax.ru/russia/763828 and interfax.ru/russia/763646). At the same time, some Russians are getting a third or even fourth shot despite official statements that there is no need for that (reuters.com/world/europe/some-russians-get-extra-covid-19-shots-sputnik-v-developers-say-no-need-2021-04-27/).

            A quasi-government organization, the Lazarev Club, has sent doses of the vaccine to Qarabagh for the use of the local population there (materik.ru/novosti/lazarevskiy-klub-otpravil-pervuyu-p/).

            On the economic front, the Kremlin has directed the government to come up with a program to aid small and mi-sized firms in especially hard-hit regions (regnum.ru/news/society/3250801.html), And the country’s banks say personal debt is now rising at unprecedented levels (rosbalt.ru/moscow/2021/04/27/1899509.html).

            Meanwhile, in other pandemic-related developments in Russia today,

·         The Bolshoy Theater has postponed all foreign appearances until March 2022 (regnum.ru/news/society/3250801.html).

·         Duma Speaker Vyacheslav Volodin says Europe should pay Russia compensation for its losses as a result of the coronavirus (regnum.ru/news/3254594.html).

·         The health ministry says Russian life expectancy declined in the pandemic year by 1.84 years as compared to 2019 (novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/04/27/minzdrav-v-2020-godu-ozhidaemaia-prodolzhitelnost-zhizni-v-rossii-snizilas-pochti-na-dva-goda).

·         The city of Moscow has used the pandemic to set up a monitoring system that now covers all public spaces in the Russian capital (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=60882EDEB5DE7).

·         Moscow accuses Brazil of politicizing the vaccine issue by its rejection of the Russian Sputnik-5 vaccine (themoscowtimes.com/2021/04/27/russia-accuses-brazil-of-political-sputnik-v-rejection-a73748).

Wednesday, April 28, 2021

Moscow’s Failure to Find Effective Responses to Foreign Moves against Russia Means There will Be More of Those, Sigov Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 26 – Many in the West are frustrated that the sanctions that they are applying to Russia have not forced a change in Moscow’s behavior, but a new commentary by Yury Sigov suggests that at least some in Moscow feel that their government’s inability to come up with effective responses to Western moves means there will be more attacks on Russia.

            The recent upsurge in anti-Russian actions not only by its “traditional” competitors but also by its former “fraternal rulers” reflects the fact that “Russia has no effective levers of influence on the surrounding world,” the Moscow journalist says. Until it finds or develops them, there will be ever more such attacks (ng.ru/ideas/2021-04-26/7_8138_offensive.html).

            According to Sizov, there are three “basic” reasons that explain the motivations for this phenomenon.  First, leaders and peoples abroad believe that since Russia destroyed their country when it tried to oppose the West, the West is in a position to push it in the same direction again given that Russia is “the legal successor of the USSR.”

            Second, many abroad feel that the Soviet Union betrayed their hopes even as it betrayed itself. That leads some to want to take revenge when they feel they can and others to approach any positive possibility in relations with Moscow extremely skeptically, especially when they are encouraged by Western leaders.

            And third, and most important, those who do take such actions are confident that Moscow won’t be able to do anything in response that will undermine their positions. It has no effective levers against most of them, and so they assume that they can act against Russia for domestic and foreign policy reasons with impunity because in the end, the US will protect them.

            This sense of impunity and “confidence that Russia today has no effective levers of influence on the world” only encourages those who see value to themselves of adopting anti-Russian positions and taking anti-Russian actions. Moscow has to find ways to show them they are wrong, or it will face a growing number of such attacks, Sizov concludes.

Central Asian Countries Increasingly Varied in Their Migration Patterns to Russia, Kazakhstan Scholar Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 26 – Most Russians and many other observers treat Central Asian migrant workers in Russia, Caress Schenk says, but there is a large and increasing diversity among them reflecting differences in the economies, social systems, and coercive capacities of the countries there. As migration rebounds after the pandemic, those differences will only increase.

            In an interview with the Central Asian Bureau for Analytic Research, the political scientist at Nazarbayev University, says that people “often fall into the trap of treating all Central Asian countries the same, and they are not,” something that is perhaps especially true regarding migration (cabar.asia/ru/kak-pandemiya-povliyala-na-migratsiyu-v-rossiyu-iz-stran-tsentralnoj-azii-intervyu-s-professorom-karess-shenk).

            Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan, the major donor countries, differ “in terms of why migrants go to Russia, how free they are to go, and how they are treated when they return to their own countries.” Kyrgyzstan is “comparatively” freer than the other two, although Uzbekistan is far looser than it was under Islam Karimov.

            As for Kazakhstan, Schenk suggests, the government is far more concerned about migration as a situation that threatens to produce “a brain drain,” a reflection that many more of its migrants to Russia are more educated and thus the loss of which to Kazakhstan represents a threat.

            The situation is Tajikistan is complicated by the country’s need for remittances and its fear that Tajiks who travel abroad will be radicalized as far as religion and politics are concerned. But despite these differences, many Central Asians now see migrant labor as a way of life, not just for survival but to achieve money to advance their status at home.

            After the pandemic wanes, she continues, Central Asian migration to Russia will bounce back. But a major issue is going to be the likelihood that Moscow will require migrants to be vaccinated against the coronavirus. That is likely to have two consequences for the flow, she suggests.

            On the one hand, that will likely lead to an increase in the share of Central Asian migrant workers in Russia without legal status. And on the other, it is likely to spark a black market in fake vaccination certificates that Central Asians can show Russian employers without ever getting their shots.

            To the extent that happens, it could easily entail massive epidemiological consequences both in Russia and in the Central Asian countries, something that will make the future of migration from Central Asia to Russia even more fraught as a political issue.