Sunday, May 2, 2021

177,000 Russians Now in Psychiatric Prisons and Most Will Die There, ‘Novaya Gazeta’ Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 30 – In a 15,000-word report, Novaya gazeta journalists Yelena Kostyuchenko and Yury Kozyrev report about the tragic circumstances in which some 177,000 Russians are now kept behind bars in psychiatric prisons, places from which few once incarcerated will leave before their deaths.

            The two journalists spent two weeks in one of these facilities as the pandemic was lifting. (While it was in full force, the situation in these facilities was truly horrific. They were almost completely closed off from the outside world. Staffs worked two-week long shifts. And many inmates got sick and died (novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/04/30/internat).

            Many of the stories are typical of mental health institutions around the world where people are warehoused after being abandoned by family members and where their rights are violated because they have no one to appeal to or because any appeal they do make is almost certain to be turned down by higher officials or the courts.

            But some of the problems they saw were unique to or at a minimum worse in Russia. According to one doctor, for 1,000 patients, he needs 5,000 staffers but after ongoing optimization, he has 40. As a result, those confined in these places aren’t treated but rather confined, something testified to by the large number who try but fail to escape.

            Because pregnancies are not allowed and yet happen, the women involved are first forced to have abortions, medical personnel say; and then the women are sterilized so that they won’t become pregnant again. The journalists also found massive corruption because the officials manipulated the numbers of inmates in different categories to get the most from the state.

            Conversations with the patients, the two journalists recount in this moving human document, led them to conclude that “when humanity disappears, only the state is left;” and for those in these institutions, the power vertical consists of the doctors and staff. They have all the power and the patients have none. Some try to help but many aren’t interested in that.

            The facility the two journalists visited was an average one, neither among the worst nor among the best, staff and patients agreed. But even it was an indictment of the system, a special circle of hell, in which “every 826th Russian spends his life and ends it there as well.”

            Appended to the article is perhaps the most important piece of information of all – a complete list of all such facilities in Russia’s regions and cities (novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/04/30/psikhonevrologicheskie-internaty-rossiiskoi-federatsii).

 

Psychological Barrier against War Rapidly ‘Thinning’ in Russia, Khabarovsk Psychologist Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 30 – The psychological barrier that fear of a new war has traditionally played in Russian life is rapidly “thinning,” Ilya Latypov says. Indeed, the word ‘war’ has now entered regular discourse not as a synonym for World War II but as a description of the current situation or a very likely future.”

            Not only does this mean that ever more Russians are asking whether there will be a war, the Khabarovsk psychologist says; it also means that ever more of them and their leaders are getting used to the idea that this is a real possibility rather than viewing it as something everyone must work against (sibreal.org/a/31231868.html).

            Patrushev is talking about Western attacks on Ivan the Terrible as efforts by Russophobes to distract attention from their own domestic problems, the US has stopped giving Russians entry visas, repression against ever more Russian groups is expanding, and ever more individuals and organizations are denounced and persecuted as “foreign agents.”

            In short, Latypov says, “the language of public policy is rapidly degrading, moving ever closer to the very bottom” when calls like those of Stalin’s prosecutor Vyshinsky to “shoot the mad dogs” seem to be just around the corner. And thus in both domestic and foreign policy, Russia seems to be moving toward a war footing.

            According to the psychologist, “history teaches us that it teaches us nothing.” Russians are ignoring how quickly things can go from bad to worse, how quickly a flourishing city like Sarajevo can go from an Olympic center to a dead place and how fast things moved in Rwanda from relative stability to mass genocide. The distance is tragically “very small.”

            One hopes that Russia can turn aside from this, that the rhetoric pointing in that direction won’t lead to actions that make a war inevitable. But people are getting used to something, the possibility of a real war, that they only recently felt was impossible. And that shift only heightens the risk that their fears will be realized.

Moscow’s Tilt toward Dushanbe May have Triggered Armed Clash between Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan, Russian Telegram Channel Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 30 – The one-day war between Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan over disputed border areas and access to enclaves which involved the armies of both countries and cost more than 20 lives and left more than 150 wounded may have been triggered by Moscow’s recent tilt toward Dushanbe, the Syto Sokrata telegram channel suggests.

            The clashes which transfixed the regional and Russian media because they involved regular military units including the air forces of the two countries ended quickly not only because the two sides recognized the risks that this clash could spread not only between the two countries but elsewhere where Tajik and Kyrgyz migrant workers currently live.

            Both the Russian and Kazakhstan governments offered to intervene to end the fighting (ritmeurasia.org/news--2021-04-30--putin-gotov-stat-posrednikom-v-reshenii-konflikta-kirgizii-i-tadzhikistana-54479 and ritmeurasia.org/news--2021-04-30--kazahstan-otreagiroval-na-konflikt-mezhdu-kyrgyzstanom-i-tadzhikistanom-54462).

            The Moscow city authorities organized a meeting between Kyrgyz and Tajik diasporas to minimize the risk that the conflict would spread to the streets of the Russian capital (nazaccent.ru/content/35658-pravitelstvo-moskvy-poprosilo-grazhdan-kirgizii-i.html). And the Russian government moved Russian teachers in Tajikistan away from the conflict zone (ria.ru/20210430/tadzhikistan-1730739727.html).

            Now, Russian analysts are focusing on the reasons behind what the Syto Sokrata telegram channel calls “a war for an hour,” and that outlet suggests that Russia played a role in triggering the latest fighting, albeit perhaps an unintentional one resulting from its broader geopolitical calculations (t.me/sytosokrata).

            Tensions between Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan over both the border itself and access to ethnic enclaves have been growing in recent months, but until this week they have not escalated beyond conflicts involving local populations and border guards given that Bishkek and Dushanbe know that expanding the conflict could threaten stability in both.

            According to Syto Sokrata, one can only be “suspicious” of Russia’s role given that the clashes occurred immediately after the visit to Dushanbe of Russian defense minister Sergey Shoygu and announcements that more Tajik military personnel will be attending Russian military training schools and taking part in Russian-led exercises.

            These developments, the channel continues, reflect Russian interest in building up Tajikistan given the planned American withdrawal from Afghanistan and Moscow’s desire to block any influx of Islamist fighters or more drug trafficking into Central Asia and ultimately into the Russian Federation.

            But more is behind Moscow’s moves than that, Syto Sokrata says. Russia needs Tajikistan to help it keep Central Asia in a sufficiently chaotic state so as to slow China’s advance. Beijing has invested in both Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan but recently has focused on the latter. Moscow is hoping to keep it that way.

            Kyrgyzstan is already “an important link” in China’s one path, one road effort, and Moscow is worried that Tajikistan may follow. Consequently, Shoygu may have suggested during his visit that Russia wants to beef up Dushanbe and thus encouraged the Tajiks to conclude that Moscow would back it in any moves against Kyrgyzstan.

            And the telegram channel suggests that this is particularly likely given Shoygu’s desire to boost his chances to succeed Putin. If Tajikistan stays within the Russian orbit and China’s position is weakened by Dushanbe’s actions, many in the Moscow elite will see Shoygu’s role in an exclusively positive light and he will gain more support there.

A Baker’s Double Dozen of Other Notable Stories from Russia This Week

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 30 – Below are 26 more stories from Russia this week that deserve to be noted because they shed significant light on Russia, its government and its people, but that I was unable to write up as full-scale Windows:   

1.      Americans Said to Fear Russian Flying Saucers. A recent US Congressional hearing about Russian defense spending focused on Moscow’s high tech innovations, leading some Russians to say that the US is worrying about an attack on the White House by Russian flying saucers (fondsk.ru/news/2021/04/29/kogda-russkie-letajuschie-tarelki-napadut-na-belyj-dom-53476.html).

2.      Russia Now Ranks First in the World in Per Capita Spending on the Military. The latest SIPRI report says that Russia now spend more per capita on its defense sector than any other major country (finanz.ru/novosti/aktsii/rossiya-operedila-vse-krupneyshie-ekonomiki-mira-po-dole-voennykh-raskhodov-v-vvp-1030344489).

3.      Almost Half of Russians Think US and NATO Behind New Tensions with Ukraine; Only Four Percent Think Russia is. A new Levada Center poll finds that 48 percent of Russians blame the US and NATO for new tensions with Ukraine, 20 percent blame Ukraine, two percent blame the DNR and LNR, and four percent blame Russia itself (levada.ru/2021/04/29/obostrenie-na-yugo-vostoke-ukrainy/).

4.      Russian Prisons Treat North Caucasians Worse than Others. Human rights activists say the evidence is clear that jailors in Russia treat inmates from the North Caucasus far worse than they do other groups (kavkaz-uzel.eu/articles/363434/).

5.      Draftee in Siberia Asked How They Feel about Revolutions. In the course of psychological testing, new draftees in Krasnoyarsk Kray have been asked about their attitude toward protests, the need for change in the country and revolutions (tayga.info/167111).

6.      ‘Like in Fascist State,’ Kremlin Now Cracking Down on Lawyers and Publishers. In addition to expanding its attacks on protesters, the Russian powers are now cracking down on lawyers who defend opposition figures, publishers the regime doesn’t like, tattoo and graffiti artists, and even pornographers whose work is viewed as anti-Kremlin (ehorussia.com/new/node/23346, graniru.org/Politics/Russia/Politzeki/m.281677.html, severreal.org/a/31226792.html svobodaradio.livejournal.com/5316747.html, novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/04/27/zapretit-tatuirovki-na-poiasnitse, snob.ru/news/sud-priostanovil-deyatelnost-soyuza-kinematografistov-v-peterburge-iz-za-artdokfesta/and snob.ru/news/sud-priostanovil-deyatelnost-soyuza-kinematografistov-v-peterburge-iz-za-artdokfesta/).

7.      Inmates who Work on BAM Will Gain Early Release. The Russian prison administration says that any prisoner who works on BAM will be given credits that will allow him or her to be released early (tass.ru/obschestvo/11270473).

8.      Putin Says Victory Day Chief and ‘Most Holy’ Russian Holiday. The May 9 holiday, Vladimir Putin says, is Russia’s chief holiday and the most holy one of all (regnum.ru/news/society/3258493.html). Meanwhile, Security Council secretary Nikolay Patrushev says Ivan the Terrible a victim of the West’s Russophobia (stoletie.ru/lenta/patrushev_nazval_ivana_groznogo_zhertvoj_rusofobskoj_propagandy_780.htm).

9.      Peskov Says Closing of Any Media Outlet Won’t Be Strongly Felt in Russia. Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov says that the shuttering of any media outlet, including those found to be “foreign agents” won’t both many Russians (novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/04/28/ischeznovenie-liubogo-smi-ne-budet-silno-oshchushchatsia-kreml-o-vnesenii-meduzy-v-reestr-inoagentov).

10.  Russia Today Journalists Highly Paid for Attacking Navalny. Journalists at RT are paid up to 750,000 rubles (10,000 US dollars) a month for their attacks on Navalny and other opposition groups (navalny.com/p/6485/). But high salaries aren’t everything, and one RT employee, Maria Butina who became infamous for her work in the US has declared she is running for the Duma on the United Russia party slate (sobkorr.org/news/60892785909B8.html).

11.   Moscow Cuts Budgets for Repatriation Program and Science. Despite its claims to the contrary, the Russian government has been cutting the amount of money it spends on programs to repatriate Russians and on science (ng.ru/politics/2021-04-28/1_8140_optimization.html and krizis-kopilka.ru/archives/85084).

12.   Moscow’s Children’s World Store May Be Forced to Move Because of Increased Cost of Rent. Landlords for Moscow’s famed Detsky mir store on Lubyanka Square say they are raising rents and that this may force the store to move to another less expensive location (forum-msk.org/material/news/17141873.html).

13.   Michelin to Rate Moscow Restaurants But No Western Audit Firms Can Check Russian Companies. The Michelin company will begin rating restaurants in the Russian capital, but the Russian government has prohibited Russian firms from asking Western firms to audit them (vedomosti.ru/lifestyle/articles/2021/04/28/868116-moskovskie-restorani and newizv.ru/news/economy/27-04-2021/rossiyskomu-biznesu-zapretili-audit-ot-inostrannyh-kompaniy).

14.   Russian Siloviki Detained Precisely 1984 Russians During April 21 Navalny Protests. In a move many will see as symbolic given George Orwell’s novel, siloviki detained exactly 1984 Russians during the most recent Navalny protests, OVD-Info says (zona.media/number/2021/04/26/21).

15.   Stalin Condemned 93,000 Soviet Citizens as Spies in 1937. Putin on His Way to Do the Same with Foreign Agents. According to historians, Stalin condemned 93,000 Soviet citizens as spies in 1937 alone, a number greater than all the spies charged by all countries in all human history. Putin appears on his way to equaling that record with foreign agents now (echo.msk.ru/programs/personalno/2827902-echo/).

16.   Moscow Procuracy Says Taking Down of Dzerzhinsky Statue in Lubyanka Square in 1991 was Illegal. Russian investigators say they can find no legal document permitting the removal of Dzerzhinsky’s statue from in front of then-KGB headquarters and thus it was an illegal act (vtimes.io/2021/04/26/prokuratura-nazvala-nezakonnim-snos-pamyatnika-dzerzhinskomu-na-lubyanke-v-1991-godu-a4723).

17.   Pamfilova Warns Putin about Work of Enemies in Upcoming Duma Elections. Election chief Ella Pamfilova has briefed Vladimir Putin about all the possible ways Russia’s enemies foreign and domestic may interfere with the upcoming Duma vote (mk.ru/politics/2021/04/26/pamfilova-predupredila-putina-o-vragakh-na-vyborakh.html).

18.   Orthodox Activists Form Militia to Defend Regime against Revolution. In an echo of the late imperial period, Orthodox Christian activists have formed a new militia to fight anyone who would try to carry out a color revolution against the Putin regime (sova-center.ru/religion/news/authorities/elections/2021/04/d44113/).

19.  Putin Admits He Doesn’t Know What all 2,000 People in Presidential Administration Do. In an interview with a US television network, Vladimir Putin admitted that he does not always know what those in his Administration are doing and so cannot always control them (apn-spb.ru/publications/article33357.htm).

20.   More than Half of Russians Support Ration Cards for Poor. A new poll shows that half of the Russian population believe that rising inflation and falling incomes justify the introduction of product cards for the country’s poorest (thinktanks.by/publication/2021/04/25/bolee-poloviny-rossiyan-podderzhivayut-vvedenie-produktovyh-kartochek-dlya-maloimuschih.html).

21.  Putin Honors Zhirinovsky on His Birthday. LDPR leader Vladimir Zhirinovsky became the 65th Russian to be invested with the order “For Services to the Fatherland” on his 65th birthday, another indication of the Kremlin’s support for him and for other systemic opposition party leaders (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=6086575805B8F).

22.  Belgorod Residents Collect 1.2 Million Rubles to Restore Lenin Memorial. Viewing it as a tourist attraction, residents of the impoverished region of Belgorod have collected 1.2 million rubles (17,000 US dollars) to restore the Lenin statue in their capital (versia.ru/1-246-828-rublej-belgorodcy-sobrali-na-vosstanovlenie-pamyatnika-leninu).

23.  Despite Appearances, Moscow Doesn’t Have a Counterpart of Leaning Tower of Pisa. A photograph that has gone viral makes it appear that a new apartment tower in the Russian capital is leaning. In fact, officials say, it is only a matter of the perspective of the photographer (nakanune.ru/news/2021/4/28/22600833/).

24.  Climate Change Threatens Survival of Nogai People in Daghestan. The spread of deserts because of global warming now threatens the survival of the Nogai, a Turkic people in Daghestan. It is costing them grazing lands they have used from time immemorial (themoscowtimes.com/2021/04/29/how-can-we-survive-when-the-land-is-gone-in-dagestan-a-proud-people-fights-the-desert-a73776).

25.  Siloviki Using AI to Fight Navalny Movement. Yezhednevny zhurnal documents the ways in which Moscow is using artificial intelligence as part of its effort to disorder and destroy the Navalny movement (ej.ru/?a=note&id=36089).

26.  As Bad as Things Are, Russian Activists Say Real Mass Repressions Begin When Siloviki Start Knocking on Doors in the Night. The detention of participants in opposition meetings are threatening, but those experienced in such things remind everyone that genuinely mass repression begins not with such arrests but with knocks on the doors of those the powers want to put behind bars (novayagazeta.ru/articles/2021/04/27/voronki-1984).

Fighting Pandemic, Moscow has Put Off Addressing Other Problems, Onishchenko Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 30 – During the pandemic, Moscow has addressed all its efforts to combatting the coronavirus, Duma deputy Gennady Onishchenko says. That was and is appropriate, but it means that many other pressing problems were not addressed, have intensified, and must be addressed soon (regnum.ru/news/3258151.html).

            Today, Russian officials reported registering 8731 new cases of infection and 397 new deaths from the coronavirus, with the figures in Moscow easing slightly but the numbers from other regions, including St. Petersburg remaining stable or going higher as the pandemic ebbed and flowed (t.me/COVID2019_official/2869 and regnum.ru/news/society/3250801.html).

            Rosstat reported that Russia had suffered 23,715 deaths from the coronavirus in March, down from February but that for the entire period of the pandemic, the country had suffered almost 250,000 deaths (meduza.io/news/2021/04/30/rosstat-v-marte-v-rossii-umerli-23-715-chelovek-s-koronavirusom-za-god-pandemii-pochti-250-tysyach).

            As Russia heads into the long holidays, Moscow officials said that vaccination centers in the capital would continue normal operations (regnum.ru/news/3257886.html), St. Petersburg reported a surge in hospitalizations over the last week (regnum.ru/news/3258723.html), and more regions said they would check visitor for the virus (regnum.ru/news/3258748.html).

            Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said that the long holidays had been introduced because of recommendations from epidemiologists (regnum.ru/news/3258368.html), and other officials said there was no basis for introducing new limitations or extending time off (regnum.ru/news/3258807.html).

            On the vaccine front, Moscow announced that Turkey had become the 63rd country to approve the Russian Sputnik-5 vaccine for use and that San Marino had become the first country in the world to vaccinate its entire population with it (sputnikvaccine.com/rus/newsroom/pressreleases/turtsiya-stala-63-y-stranoy-v-kotoroy-zaregistrirovana-vaktsina-sputnik-v/ and vz.ru/world/2021/4/30/1097250.html).

            Officials in various regions continued to offer payments to Russians getting the shot, and researchers said that they have released the first vaccine for animals (https://www.eastrussia.ru/news/po-tysyache-rubley-zaplatyat-pozhilym-zhitelyam-kolymy-za-privivku-ot-covid-19/ and https://regnum.ru/news/3258024.html).

            On the economic front, the rate of decline of incomes in Russia has accelerated 400 percent in recent weeks, and inflation is going up, with prices for medicines leading the way in 90 percent of the country’s federal subjects (krizis-kopilka.ru/archives/85116 and krizis-kopilka.ru/archives/85114).

            In an effort to calm the situation, Kremlin spokesman Peskov said that as bad as things are in Russia, they are worse in other countries (trtrussian.com/novosti-rossiya/u-drugih-eshe-huzhe-kreml-nadeetsya-ostanovit-padenie-dohodov-v-etom-godu-5307321).

            Meanwhile, in other pandemic-related developments in Russia today,

·         Duma deputy Gennady Onishchenko says the safest place to be in Russia on May 9 as far as the virus is concerned is Red Square (regnum.ru/news/3258248.html).

·         In many places, Russian Orthodox and Muslim groups are taking parallel measures in response to the pandemic during their overlapping holidays (regnum.ru/news/3258455.html).

·         Officials in Stavropol plan to mark May Day with a ceremony in which they will burn an effigy of the coronavirus (regnum.ru/news/3258505.html).

Saturday, May 1, 2021

Putin, Speaking to French Businessmen, Seeks to Calm Domestic Worries about the Growing Isolation of Russia, Psychologist Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 29 – Today, Vladimir Putin told an online meeting with leading French businessmen that if Europe under American pressure increases sanctions on Russia, Europeans will pay and only the Americans will benefit, and thus that any attempt by Europeans to isolate Russia will prove counterproductive.

            Moscow social psychologist Aleksey Roshchin says that Putin’s message was directed “not so much at the Europeans as at the Russians” because the threat of new sanctions will only “intensify the fear of international isolation” among Russians,” something “which the authorities must remove” (ura.news/articles/1036282250).

            “Russians don’t quite understand how much we depend on the West,” the psychologist says; “but there is a broad understanding that it is a bad thing to be an outcast.” They have seen their incomes fall and foreign products disappear from the shelves of Russian stores. And this is helping to shape their attitudes about the upcoming Duma elections.

            The URA news agency notes that “there are no fresh publicly available sociological studies about the concerns of Russians about international isolation.” The last time one did appear, in 2018, 56 percent of Russians said they felt the country was isolated, the highest figure since such questions appeared in surveys.

            But there is one indirect piece of evidence to support Roshchin’s contention. A just-completed VTsIOM poll found that Russians now rank worries about conflicts between Russia and other countries in fourth place among the things they say they worry about. Only a few months ago, that concern was far further down the list, at eighth place.

Digital Divide in Russia Between Largest Cities and Everywhere Else, HSE Study Finds

Paul Goble

            Staunton, April 29 – Earlier research has found that in Russia as in other countries, younger and more educated cohorts are more likely to be regular users of electronic media while older and less educated are likely to be less comfortable with that format. Now, a new HSE study shows that the real digital divide is between the largest cities and the rest.

            In a research just presented at the 22nd April International Scientific Conference, HSE researchers report that 61.3 percent of residents of Russian cities with populations of more than a million and 56.3 percent of those in cities having between 500,000 and a million are computer competent (iq.hse.ru/news/465308186.html).

            But residents of small settlements, ranging from cities under 500,000 to villages, had a much smaller rate of computer competence, with all of them having between 47 and 49 percent on that rating. Much of this difference is the product of differences in educational attainment, but it is striking that people in mall cities are no more computer competent than that of villages.

            It may be that this reflects the greater propensity of village residents to turn to the Internet given the absence of other forms of information and entertainment that may be more widely available even in the smallest cities. But in most countries, residents of smaller cities do relatively better than in Russia.

            As far as overall computer competence is concerned, Russia ranks 48th out of 134 countries around the world, but its regional distribution of internet use is more like those at the lower end of that ranking than it is among the leaders like Sweden, Denmark, Singapore, the Netherlands, Switzerland, Finland, Norway, the US, Germany and the UK.