Paul Goble
Staunton, Jan. 14 – The Putin regime is busily fighting the manifestations of separatism like the display of regional flags even as it foolishly and unnecessarily creates the grounds for separatism by its own policies, according to Anatoly Nesmiyan, who blogs under the screen name El Murid.
“Separatism arises as an extreme reaction to the actions of a government which oppresses its regions, deprives them of the chance for independent development, and sucks the resources out of them -- that is, when it acts as a metropolis to colonies,” El Murid argues (t.me/anatoly_nesmiyan/22918 reposted at kasparov.ru/material.php?id=678760380E05F).
In almost every country, there are some people in the regions who call for separatism, he continues; “but in a normal country, they are always marginal and do not have any serious support so there is no particular point in banning them because the absence of such support means that they are no threat.”
However, “if ‘the central government’ creates the conditions for separatism, then it will arise regardless of prohibitions” about its superficial manifestations. Indeed, “at some point, it and no other position “will become the defining idea” and that state as an integral whole will come to an end.
Under Putin, El Murid suggests, “the Russian government has lost the ability to govern. Moscow can still control through prohibitions, terror and repression, but it can no longer manage. Control achieved by these means will work for a time; but as soon as it weakens, the situation will change quickly and dramatically.”
Russia should be “a natural federation, a natural union of regions,” the commentator argues; and “attempts to create a centralized administration on its territory” have made sense only when Russia was growing territorially or when it was undergoing a radical shift from one kind of socio-economic-political order to another.
The Kremlin may imagine that it is doing both, but its military expansion is costing it more than it can afford to pay and it has no development project for the country’s transformation. Hence, its hyper-centralization is an increasingly dangerous mistake in a country that should be by its diverse nature a federation.
Russia’s problems, despite what the Kremlin seems to think, are not with the flag of the Urals Republic which it has now banned but with Moscow policies that are forcing ever more people in the regions to think about separatism if genuine federalism remains an impossible goal under the current ruler, El Murid says.
And he reminds his readers of something most of them have forgotten: “Today’s Russia arose precisely because of the actions of separatists led by Yeltsin who was behind the declaration of Russian sovereignty. That day is now a national holiday” not only of Russia but of the power of separatism if the center misuses its powers.
Friday, January 17, 2025
Kremlin Foolishly and Unnecessarily Creating Grounds for Separatism in Russia, El Murid Says
Aleksandr Shchipkov – Soviet-Era Dissident who is Now Chief Ideologist of the ROC MP
Paul Goble
Staunton, Jan. 14 – Few Russian Orthodox figures have undergone as great an evolution as Aleksandr Shchipkov who in Soviet times attacked both the Moscow church and the Soviet state and worked as a correspondent for Britain’s Keston College but now serves as a propagandist for the hardest of hard liners among the ROC MP and its allies in the government.
Born in Leningrad (now St. Petersburg) in 1957, Shchipkov grew up in a liberal Orthodox family and was a follower of Father Dudko. He has said that at that time, his slogan was “Christianity, freedom and anti-communism” but now he celebrates the Soviet system as consistent with Orthodoxy (novayagazeta.eu/articles/2025/01/14/kresty-i-lampasy).
Moreover, he serves not only as an advisor to the patriarch but to leading Russian officials but also as a spokesman for the church. In both capacities, he goes far beyond even the official line: he insists Russia has had an ideology for a decade despite constitutional bans and that Europe as a whole and not just Ukraine has become a bastion of re-Nazification.
Because of Shchipkov’s background as a dissident, some in the West are inclined to see him as a bridge to the Orthodox leadership in Russia today; but that is almost certainly a mistake. He is now more Orthodox than the Patriarch and likely will remain so given that his positions are close to what the Kremlin really thinks but has not yet been ready to articulate publicly.
The article in Novaya Gazeta tracks his evolution which seems to reflect less something driven by intellectual reflection than about seizing the main chance for career advancement and a willingness to use the kind of repressive measures against his opponents that some in the Russian church as yet have been less willing to engage in.
Almost certainly, Shchipkov’s views, as presented at websites he controls -- religare.ru and shchipkov.ru – serve as an indication of the direction the thinking of the Kremlin and the Patriarchate in the years of mature Putinism not only is proceeding now but is likely to go in the future.
Ukraine and Moldova Too May Soon Cease to Exist along with Other States that Mistreat Russians , Patrushev Says
Paul Goble
Staunton, Jan. 14 – Nikolay Patrushev, the former secretary of the Russian Security Council who now is a Putin assistant and confidant, says that Ukraine may cease to exist already this year, that Moldova may do the same shortly thereafter and that other states which mistreat ethnic Russians may ultimately share the same fate.
In a brief interview with Komsomolskaya Pravda, the Russian hardliner suggests that these countries have no one to blame but themselves and says that their policies rather than Russian pressure and in the case of Ukraine direct attacks are responsible for the destruction of “once flourishing” cities (kp.ru/daily/27651/5036217/).
The fate of Ukraine and possibly the others should be discussed in talks “between Russia and the US without the participation of other countries of the West,” Patrushev continues. The reason is simple: Neither London nor Brussels has the right to speak for Europe because many European countries now agree with Moscow rather than with Washington.
But in any such talks, he says, Moscow is not going to make any territorial concessions. The only thing these conversations will be about is getting the West and Ukraine to accept the rules of the game that Vladimir Putin has repeatedly outlined, rules that will “de-Nazify” Ukraine and keep it out of Western alliances.
Patrushev is not the only Kremlin advisor who has the ear of Putin, but he is among the most influential and his hardline position likely gives the Kremlin leader confident that those around him are quite prepared to do whatever is necessary to achieve their ends and reject any American or Western efforts to deprive Moscow of a victory.
Thursday, January 16, 2025
Kremlin’s Pro-Natalist Policies Pushing Up Fertility Rates among Central Asian Immigrants, Making Officials Look Good but Likely Increasing Non-Russian Share of Population
Paul Goble
Staunton, Jan. 14 – The Kremlin’s pro-natalist policies are backfiring at least in one respect, observers say: Officials are giving special benefits to already large families from Central Asia because they are more likely to have additional children than are indigenous ethnic Russians who have fewer and don’t qualify for these arrangements.
As a result, local and regional officials can point to increases in the number and size of large families, something the Kremlin now evaluates their performance on; but this is achieved by boosting births among non-Russians rather than among ethnic Russians, increasing the relative size of the first community relative to the second (nakanune.ru/articles/123035/).
Some ethnic Russians, already concerned about the declining share of the population of the Russian Federation their nation represents, are alarmed; but so far, they have had little luck in getting officials to modify pro-natalist policies and the evaluation of their success to that the benefits flow first to the ethnic Russians and not to Central Asians.
And Russian anger on this point is likely to grow as members of the titular nationality see that the number of Central Asian children in their schools is rising faster than that of ethnic Russians – and that this is taking place as a result of policies put in place by a government that claims to be doing what it can to make Russia more Russian.
With Advance in Ukraine’s Donetsk Oblast, Moscow has Gained Control of Lithium Deposit Larger than All Such Reserves in US
Paul Goble
Staunton, Jan. 14 – With its military advance in Ukraine’s Donetsk Oblast, the Russian Federation has increased its reserves of lithium, sometimes referred to as “the new oil,” by more than 14 times and now has more lithium under its control than does the United States, Elena Rychkova of the Nakanune news agency reports.
Prior to this advance, Moscow controlled only about one million tons of lithium reserves, mostly around Murmansk, but having seized the land around Shevchenko in Donetsk Oblast, it has an estimated 14.8 million tons, about two million tons that the known reserves in the US (nakanune.ru/articles/123027/).
Russian experts say that Moscow will not begin exploiting this for a year or two and will need to expand its control around Shevchenko in order to ensure that it fully controls the deposit. Given the importance of lithium in electronics and China’s relatively small reserves, Beijing is likely to want to be involved as well.
Warsaw May Restrict Repatriation of Poles from Russia Out of Fear that Among Them are Spies
Paul Goble
Staunton, Jan. 14 – The Polish government is now confronted with a situation many other countries are and that Moscow may be counting on to restrict emigration of people with ethnic ties to other countries: Warsaw, fearful that among ethnic Poles from Russia seeking repatriation there may be spies, is considering ending the repatriation program it has had in place.
Maciej Duszczyk, Poland’s deputy foreign minister, says that Warsaw may take that step because it can’t allow a situation to arise in which an individual from Russia with Polish links may be “part of the Russian KGB” (kresy.pl/wydarzenia/rodacy-ze-wschodu-moga-stracic-prawo-do-repatriacji-wiceminister-tlumaczy-to-wzgledami-bezpieczenstwa/).
His words, even if Warsaw doesn’t act on them, call attention to a problem many countries have with co-ethnics from Russia: Moscow has used them to place spies in other countries and used suspicions about them to force some among these diasporas to cooperate with Soviet and now Russian intelligence services.
And because that is the case, Moscow may be just as pleased that this possibility is being discussed in the Polish capital given that it is likely to be picked up elsewhere in Europe, the Middle East and the United States where there are sizeable diasporas that Moscow has used and will be able to use even more often if suspicions about them increase.
Duma Defense Committee Member Wants Russia to have Military Base in Svalbard and Control of Portions of Greenland
Paul Goble
Staunton, Jan. 13 – Andrey Gurulyev, a United Russia member of the Duma’s defense committee and former Russian general in Ukraine and Syria, has called for Moscow to establish a military base on Svalbard (Spitzbergen) and to seize portions of Greenland to prevent the US from using either against Moscow.
He made those remarks on the Moscow TV talk show, “Evening with Vladimir Solovyov,” and he is far from being judicious: Gurulyev earlier called for nuking part of Europe. In reporting his latest outburst, The Barents Observer described him as “a halfwit lawmaker” (thebarentsobserver.com/news/halfwit-lawmaker-says-russia-should-establish-bases-on-svalbard/423172).
But Gurulyov’s words should not be entirely ignored as they reflect a prominent trend among the most nationalist elements of the ruling party of the Russian Federation and suggest that if Putin were to move in either of the directions the deputy has now proposed, the Kremlin leader would enjoy significant support at home.