Thursday, June 2, 2022

Putin’s Behavior Makes Sense If He’s in Fact a Western Agent Sent to Destroy Russia, Zaidman Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, May 17 – Many Russians to this day are certain that Mikhail Gorbachev and his entourage were Western agents charged with destroying the USSR. Now, at least some are speculating that the same thing may be true of Vladimir Putin whose disastrous policies only make sense if that is the case, Vadim Zaidman says.

            The Russian commentator points out that he raised this possibility a decade ago (rubezh.eu/Zeitung/2011/12/00.htm) but that there seems to be ever more evidence that this is the only adequate explanation for Putin policies that hurt rather than help Russia and put it on the

            The Kremlin leader’s war in Ukraine, something completely senseless from the point of view of Russian interests, Zaidman continues, makes perfect sense if he is in fact a Western agent sent to destroy Russia. After all, no Russian leader ever has taken so many steps to destroy his own country.

            “If you think about it,” he says, “there is nothing improbable in this version of events. Russian government officials an patriots … are always asserting that the US and in general the West are constantly thinking about how they can demolish and destroy Russia. What would be surprising if they actually undertook steps” like this toward that goal?

            Those who ask where is the evidence for the assertion that “Putin is an agent of the State Department” need only look around. Putin’s actions are all the evidence anyone could possibly need. After all, Zaidman says, “if Putin looks like an agent of the State Department, talks like an agent of the State Department and most important acts like one, perhaps in fact, he is.”

            To be sure, Zaidman doesn’t really believe what he is saying; but the fact that he is saying what likely many other Russians given as they frequently are to conspiratorial thinking and the assumption that invisible forces are behind everything, this perspective further undermines Putin and his standing with his own population, just as it did with Gorbachev.

Peskov’s Claim that Putin ‘Knows What He’s Doing’ Highlights Fears that He Doesn’t, Denisenko Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, May 17 – When people are confident that their leaders know what they are doing, no one around them feels the need to speak about that. But once people begin to doubt that those in charge in fact do know “what they are doing,” then those around them feel compelled to claim exactly that.

            That is the real meaning of Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov’s recent statement that Putin “knows what he is doing,” Vadim Denisenko, the director of the Ukrainian Institute of the Future (gordonua.com/blogs/vadim-denisenko/process-razvala-rossii-zapushchen-samimi-rossiyanami-no-my-k-sozhaleniyu-ne-mozhem-spokoyno-sidet-na-beregu-reki-i-zhdat-trup-vraga-1609405.html).

            In the short term, Denisenko says, such statements may lead even more Russians to rally around Putin because the Kremlin leader’s destruction of alternatives and repression against any who seek them make that a logical policy. But over the longer term, these words suggest that the Putin regime is heading toward its end.

            If the population has to be reassured that those in charge do know what they are doing, that means not only that ever more people are beginning to think otherwise but also that they are searching for alternatives. Eventually some will appear; and if Russians conclude that they are a better alternative than the current leader, he and his system will collapse.

            This is a strictly internal dynamic within the Russian system, the Ukrainian politician and analyst says; but it is something that Russia’s neighbors and the world can’t afford to ignore because if Russia changes, their situation will change as well.

 

Wednesday, June 1, 2022

Moscow Denounces Ecumenical Patriarch for Reportedly Seeking to Expel Russian Monks from Mount Athos in Greece

Paul Goble

            Staunton, May 16 – Bartholemew, Orthodoxy’s ecumenical patriarch who has already infuriated Moscow by his grant of autocephaly to Ukraine’s faithful, has now reportedly taken another step that will only deepen the divide between the Russian Orthodox Church and the portions of the Orthodox world which look to him.

            According to as yet unconfirmed reporting, the ecumenical patriarch has asked Athens to approve his plans to expel from monasteries in Mount Athos, long a center of monasticism in the Orthodox world, all ethnic Russian priests – there are fewer than 100 -- and others more numerous allied with Moscow. Batholemew reportedly is calling them “a nest of Putin agents” (russian7.ru/post/v-rpc-opasayutsya-chto-russkie-monakhi-mog/ and stoletie.ru/rossiya_i_mir/amerikanskaja_metla_392.htm).

            The Moscow Patriarchate has already denounced this move, but if Bartholemew does carry it out, such a step will echo broadly among Orthodox Russians more generally because Mount Athos has long been an important pilgrimage site for the Russian faithful. And that will cement permanently the divide between Moscow and Constantinople.

            Not surprisingly given the current climate, both the ROC MP and allied Russian commentators have blamed this move on the United States, arguing that the universal patriarch is not an independent religious leader but rather a cat’s paw for American imperialism and its Russophobic attitudes.

 

Russia’s Construction Sites in Arctic Risk Becoming ‘Ghost Towns,’ Barents Observer Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, May 16 – Just like the Soviet cities in the Far North which in many cases ceased to exist once Moscow’s subsidies disappeared along with the USSR, so too many of Russia’s largest construction centers in the Arctic, key parts of Vladimir Putin’s program for that region, are now at risk of becoming “ghost towns,” Atle Staalesen says.

            The Barents Observer analyst says that among the ones most likely to suffer that fate is Novatek’s LNG Construction Center near Murmansk now that China has followed European countries in pulling out of the project (thebarentsobserver.com/ru/promyshlennost-i-energiya/2022/05/krupneyshie-arkticheskie-stroyki-mogut-stat-gorodami-prizrakami).

            If that project grinds to a complete halt, many of the 20,000 workers there will be left unemployed, housing prices will collapse and regional government revenues will decline, adding to the list of sanctions-induced problems, including image ones, now facing the Russian government.  

Only 53 Percent of Kadyrov’s Forces in Ukraine Consist of Ethnic Chechens, Kyiv Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, May 16 – Ukraine’s intelligence service has established that only 53 percent of the men who are listed as volunteers from Chechnya are in fact ethnic Chechens. The remainder are overwhelmingly ethnic Russians (gur.gov.ua/content/u-viiskovomu-vtorhnenni-v-ukrainu-bralo-uchast-blyzko-25-tysiach-boiovykiv-z-chechenskoi-respubliky.html).

            Given the attention Ramzan Kadyrov’s units have attracted because of their numbers and brutality in Ukraine, this finding is important in at least three ways. First, it suggests that the Chechen boss has been far less successful in attracting Chechens to his units than he claims despite his use of repressive measure to get people under his control to “volunteer.”

            Second, it helps to explain conflicts between Kadyrov’s unit and others in the Russian invasion force such as the Buryats, something that may have less to do with hostility among non-Russians than with hostility between all non-Russians and the ethnic Russians who dominate the Russian command if not always its lower ranks.

            And third – and this is far and away the most important – it indicates that much of the brutality that the Kadyrov force has engaged in has less to do with Chechens than with Putin loyalist Kadyrov’s desire to show how tough he is even if he has to do it with ethnic Russians who may be far more guilty than many suppose.

            Following the publication of this data, and the Ukrainians offer a list of the names on which they draw the conclusions about the numbers, Moscow propagandists will no longer be able to credibly claim that the Chechens and other non-Russians are responsible for any crimes against humanity in Ukraine.

            These numbers show that the ethnic Russians are playing the dominate role even when they are operating in nominally “Chechen” units.

Nearly Ten Percent Fewer Russians Identify Now as Orthodox than Did a Decade Ago, Levada Center Poll Finds

Paul Goble

            Staunton, May 16 – Despite the Kremlin’s promotion of Orthodoxy as a key element of Russian identity, nine percent fewer Russians now identify as Orthodox by identity and significantly fewer take part in church activities than did a decade ago, according to surveys conducted by the independent Levada Center.

            Those findings, available at levada.ru/2022/05/16/religioznye-predstavleniya/ and trtrussian.com/novosti-rossiya/kolichestvo-pravoslavnyh-v-rossii-sokratilos-za-poslednie-desyatiletiya-8865903, differ from those of government-related surveys that suggest Russian religiosity has remained at high levels (fom.ru/TSennosti/14717).

            The Levada Center reports appear far more credible, and what they show must be disturbing to many of the traditionalists who now dominate the ideological thinking of the Putin regime. Only 53 percent of Russians say they are religious at all, with 33 percent saying they aren’t very religious and 16 percent declaring they aren’t religious at all.

            Forty-three percent say they never take part in religious services; 17 percent more say they do so less than once a year, and only 14 percent say they do so more of than that, with only eight percent declaring that they do so more often than once a month, the Levada Center surveys show.

            Of Russian residents of all nationalities who do declare a religion, 71 percent identify as Orthodox, five percent as Muslims, and one percent each Buddhists, Catholics and Protestants. Another four percent say they are atheists, while 15 percent indicate that they do not identify with any religion.

Great Fatherland War Ideology ‘Not Simply Useless but Counterproductive’ in Promoting Unity of Former Soviet Space, Gorynych Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, May 16 – Vladimir Putin has made the commemoration of the Soviet victory in World War II the centerpiece of his ideology in Russia, but that ideology, Nikita Gorynych says, is “not simply useless but counterproductive” when it comes to uniting the former Soviet space into a single Russian Empire.

            Instead of unifying the various peoples as Moscow hopes, the Topcor commentator says, the war is now being used by non-Russian elites to mobilize people on an anti-Russian basis and drive them further from Moscow and thus inevitably closer to the Western world (topcor.ru/25687-u-rossii-est-dva-puti-vosstanovlenija-byloj-moschi-mjagkij-i-zhestkij.html).

            To prevent that and instead attract the former Soviet borderlands, he continues, Moscow mustn’t continue to try to rely on “the recasting of old Bolshevik slogans and conceptions, the creation of shaky and ineffective unions like the Eurasian Economic Community, the Tariff Union, the CIS or the Organization for the Collective Security Treaty.”

            Instead, Moscow must move constantly toward “the restoration of Russia in its full territorial and ideological meaning,” one based on the construction of the state on the basis of the principles of Orthodoxy and the service of Truth, a big project that alone can attract not only the triune Russian nation but also non-Russians and non-Orthodox communities as well.

            In this conception, he says, “the state and the ruler are defenders of the entire Orthodox world. That conception led to the growth of Russia which was doomed by fate to become an Empire” in which all peoples would benefit from the security and peace it alone could and can provide. If it remains fragmented, the region will be plagued by wars.

            Gorynych’s observations come in the course of his discussion of whether Moscow should adopt a hard or a soft approach to rebuilding the empire. The first involves the use of force and the second a revival of ideological unity through the promotion of the Orthodox principles he says are needed for peace and security.

            Even if force is used, a renewed commitment to this larger ideological project is needed because unless it is, Moscow will continue to be viewed by the non-Russian statelets as “more dangerous” than the West because it is closer. And so they base themselves on hostility to Russia. Only if their peoples recognize how short-sighted such an approach is can there be hope.

            For an empire to work, one people and its values must be at the center. “In the Roman Empire, this people was the Romans. In the American, the Anglo-Saxon Puritans; and in the Russia it can only be the triune Russian people (Great Russians, Little Russians and Belarusians)” with a shared “Idea of a Just World” based on Orthodox teaching.

`           The events of the last century have distracted the peoples of this region from these principles, he argues. Now, they must be recovered as the basis of soft power either on its own or in combination with hard power that is required for the reconstitution of the Russian Empire that will benefit all its peoples.