Saturday, January 25, 2025

Ukraine at Risk of ‘Somalization’ if West Suddenly Ends Aid to Force Talks, Moscow Analyst Says

Paul Goble
    Staunton, Jan. 22 – Russian analysts are beginning to focus on what may happen as the West pushes both Russia and Ukraine to reach a settlement on the war, with some expressing alarm that the process itself could produce consequences that few are focusing on and that no one should want.
    One Russian analyst who has focused on these possibilities is Iosif Diskin, an economist at the HSE, who says that if the West suddenly cut off assistance to Kyiv to force it to reach an agreement, that could lead to “the Somalization” of Ukraine and “trigger a new phase” in the conflict (mk.ru/politics/2025/01/22/nazvan-trigger-kotoryy-zapustit-novuyu-fazu-ukrainskogo-krizisa.html).
    Without Western assistance, Kyiv would lose much of the leverage it has over various places and institutions across Ukraine, Diskin suggests, and that could lead to warlordism and the spread of uncontrolled violence not only within its borders but across them into other countries, exactly the opposite of what those pushing for talks and an agreement presumably want.

Friday, January 24, 2025

Putin’s Orders about Shipbuilding Aren’t Being Carried Out, Patrushev Says

Paul Goble
    Staunton, Jan. 22 – In what sounds like the justification for a purge if things don’t change soon, Nikolay Pastrushev, the presidential assistant who heads the Maritime Collegium, says that Putin’s order aren’t be carried out in the shipbuilding branch aren’t being carried out and the sector’s systemic problems aren’t being resolved.
    He made his remarks at a meeting of educational institutions and shipbuilding industry enterprises in St. Petersburg and his words may be little more than a manifestation of Patrushev’s frustration and tendency to express his opinions in the most dramatic way possible (eadaily.com/ru/news/2025/01/23/patrushev-porucheniya-prezidenta-ne-ispolnyayutsya-sistemnye-problemy-ne-reshayutsya).
    But given Patrushev’s position as one of Putin’s closest confidants and the all-too-obvious problems of Russia’s shipbuilding sector which is under increasing sanctions, his words may point to a purge there that could rapidly broaden into a broader attack on officials across the board. Indeed, it is possible that that is exactly what Putin wants people to conclude.

In Chukotka, Moscow Replaces Independent Whaling Group with Puppet One in Name of National Security but Destroying Way of Life of Indigenous Peoples

Paul Goble
    Staunton, Jan. 22 – Putin’s increasing repression is so widespread that it is typically described in broadbrush terms, something that has the effect of hidings its insidious nature and the very specific negative consequences it has not just for well-known dissidents but entirely unknown groups of people.
    That makes a report by Cherta journalists Lana Pulayeva and Anastasiya Martynov about how the Russian state first destroyed an NGO that sought to help the native peoples of Chukotka restore whale hunting 20 years ago and then put in its place a totally government-controlled entity that did the state’s business rather than the people’s (cherta.media/story/kitoboi/).
    Local officials working with the FSB took this step, the journalists say, on the pretext of defending national security: the independent NGO had received a grant from the University of Alaska and thus became in the eyes of the Russian powers that be “a foreign agent” that had to be driven out of existence.
    The group the state authorities put in its place was made up not of peoples directly affected by the whaling industry but by officials who could be counted on to do what Moscow wanted. In this case, it worked to promote the dispatch of indigenous peoples to fight in Ukraine rather than help those peoples maintain their ancient economic practices and survive.
    Palayeva and Martynova describe how this occurred, with the state using a step by step approach recalling the famous story about how the frog was cooked after the water in which it was placed was gradually warmed to the boiling point. That is what is happening to the people of Chukotka who are now disappearing faster, people say, than the Arctic species they have hunted.

Secularist and Democratic Ichkerian Army Taking Shape in Ukraine

Paul Goble
    Staunton, Jan. 20 – When the people of Chechnya began their struggle for independence at the end of Soviet times, their leaders were committed to a vision of a secular and democratic country. When the West didn’t back them, some of them turned to Islamist radicals further alienating many. But now, the Chechens are changing again.
    In Russian-occupied Chechnya, Ramzan Kadyrov has installed a kind of pseudo-Islamic state that imposes many of the dicta of the Muslim faith as state policy. But despite the assumptions of many that Chechens are Islamist, assumptions Moscow has encouraged, a new generation is arising that is fighting for the original ideals of democracy and secularism.
    This remarkable and transformative idea has received little attention, but Akhmed Zakayev, head of the exile Chechen Republic Ichkeria government, explains how it is happening and why (kavkazr.com/a/v-ukraine-my-stali-organizovannoy-strukturoy-ahmed-zakaev-o-svobodnoy-chechne-i-rezhime-kadyrova/33282063.html).
    He points out that in contrast to the first generation which fled Chechnya after the Russian advance and often fell under the influence of Islamist groups in the Middle East, the new generation of Chechens living in Europe, some 400,000 in all, have been shaped by Western institutions and values.
    They have gone to Western universities and absorbed Western values, and some of them have now formed five battalions of a Chechen force to alongside Ukrainians against Russian aggression. This force, which has come into existence in Ukraine, is the foundation of forces which will restore the original ideals of the Chechen movement.

Wednesday, January 22, 2025

With Assad’s Ouster, Moscow Set to Lose Important Church Ally in Orthodox World

Paul Goble
    Staunton, Jan. 18 – Assad’s ouster not only is likely to cost Russia its military bases in Syria but also to drive from office the leader of the Antioch Patriarchate who had distinguished himself both by his pro-Assad positions and his support for the Moscow Patriarchate regarding Ukrainian autocephaly and Putin’s war in Ukraine.
    Now with Assad and his Russian supporters gone, Syria’s Antioch Change Movement has called for the resignation of Patriarch John X who in its view had “sullied himself” by collaborating with Assad and  Putin” (novayagazeta.eu/articles/2025/01/18/antiokhiia-posle-asada).
    The Movement is likely to be successful given that John X has many enemies in Syria given that he and Assad changed church rules so that he could be elected in the first place, he failed to investigate the murders of senior churchmen, and he slavishly followed Damascus and Moscow in his policies.
    John’s removal will affect the 500,000 Christians in Syria, but more than that, it will echo across the Orthodox world, not only because there are roughly three million more Antioch Christians in other countries but because the Antioch Patriarchate ranks third among the ancient Orthodox patriarchates, behind only Constantinople and Alexandria.
    Up to now, the Antioch Patriarchate has been the Moscow Patriarchate’s most reliable ally in Moscow’s dispute with Constantinople. Now, the Russian church won’t be able to count on a similarly close ally in the future – and that likely means the ROC MP will be more isolated in the Orthodox world than at any time since the death of Stalin.
    That in turn will mean that the ROC MP will have less to offer the Kremlin and that it will feel compelled to follow ever more closely Putin’s nationalist and imperialist line.

‘Russia isn’t the USSR, Ukraine isn’t Finland, and Putin isn’t Stalin’ – Shelin on Why Old Models of Conflict Resolution Won’t Work for Ukraine

Paul Goble
    Staunton, Jan. 17 – In talk about what kind of a deal Russia and the West might make about Ukraine, many are looking back to Finland and other conflicts where settlements were reached between Moscow and the West in Soviet times. But that is a mistake, Sergey Shelin argues.
    The situation is too dissimilar because “the Russian Federation is not the USSR, Ukraine is not Finland, and Putin is not Stalin,” according to the Russian commentator. The latter difference is especially important because of Putin, the Ukrainian conflict is existential (moscowtimes.ru/2025/01/17/starie-primeri-ne-podoidut-rf-ne-sssr-ukraina-ne-finlyandiya-a-putin-ne-stalin-a152557).
    “In my opinion,” Shelin says after reviewing each of the clashes from the past, “no one should count on the implementation in 2025 of any of the settlement schemes from the past and constantly being discussed. The talks being organized by Trum apparently are destined to involve the banal surrender of Ukraine, reach a dead end, or go off in some unconventional direction.”
    Indeed, he continues, “nothing for example prevents Trump from personally guaranteeing Putin’s personal security and promising that he will not allow anyone to touch him. Maybe this is the key to all the problems. But Putin likely proceeds from the fact that Trump as president is not eternal while he, Putin, is.”
    “But there are many ways to play on personal obsessions,” Shelin concludes, “and some of them may work.”


Paul Goble
    Staunton, Jan. 17 – In talk about what kind of a deal Russia and the West might make about Ukraine, many are looking back to Finland and other conflicts where settlements were reached between Moscow and the West in Soviet times. But that is a mistake, Sergey Shelin argues.
    The situation is too dissimilar because “the Russian Federation is not the USSR, Ukraine is not Finland, and Putin is not Stalin,” according to the Russian commentator. The latter difference is especially important because of Putin, the Ukrainian conflict is existential (moscowtimes.ru/2025/01/17/starie-primeri-ne-podoidut-rf-ne-sssr-ukraina-ne-finlyandiya-a-putin-ne-stalin-a152557).
    “In my opinion,” Shelin says after reviewing each of the clashes from the past, “no one should count on the implementation in 2025 of any of the settlement schemes from the past and constantly being discussed. The talks being organized by Trum apparently are destined to involve the banal surrender of Ukraine, reach a dead end, or go off in some unconventional direction.”
    Indeed, he continues, “nothing for example prevents Trump from personally guaranteeing Putin’s personal security and promising that he will not allow anyone to touch him. Maybe this is the key to all the problems. But Putin likely proceeds from the fact that Trump as president is not eternal while he, Putin, is.”
    “But there are many ways to play on personal obsessions,” Shelin concludes, “and some of them may work.”


Tuesday, January 21, 2025

Moscow Patriarch Believes His Church Can Regain Following It Lost in 2022 Only By Becoming More Pro-War, Dubrovsky Says

Paul Goble    
    Staunton, Jan. 17 – When Putin began his expanded war against Ukraine, Dmitry Dubrovsky says, the Russian Orthodox Church of the Moscow Patriarchate lost many of its parishioners because “even pro-war, pro-Putin ones did not expect the fierce pro-war rhetoric the church offered.”
    Such attitudes and the flight from the Moscow church they have produced has created a behind the scenes conflict within the church, the Russian sociologist who now teachers at Charles University in Prague says, and there is “real tension growing within the church” (svoboda.org/a/rusofobiya-po-putinski/33278107.html).
    What is striking and perhaps somewhat unexpected is how the head of the church, Patriarch Kirill has decided to respond. He appears to believe that “the only way out of this … is to rally around Putin even more closely,” despite the fact that this may drive more believers away and leave his hierarchy ever more a tightly controlled appendage of the Russian state.