Paul Goble
Staunton,
February 9 – One of the most intriguing developments of rapid modernization around
the world is the way that old social structures, groups and identities which many
expect to pass away as a result of social change in fact re-emerge to play new
and sometimes more powerful roles long after their demise was predicted or even
claimed by new rulers.
Indeed,
it often happens that modernization provokes exactly that response among those
who are supposed to be absorbed by new groups and identities and thus disappear.
That happened in Iran at the end of the shah’s time, in Afghanistan following
the Soviet invasion, and in various Western countries in response to globalization,
to name but three.
Now,
it is happening in Ingushetia largely as a result of the overreach of republic
head Yunus-Bek Yevkurov and his September 26 border deal with Chechnya’s Ramzan
Kadyrov. Thousands of Ingush went into
the streets for more than a month to protest, and their activism has led to a
dramatic increase in the political role now of a most ancient Ingush structure.
That
is the teip, a tribe or clan, that
has been the basic structure of Ingush society from time immemorial and that is
embedded in the name of every Ingush to this day, despite Russian, Soviet and
post-Russian efforts to move beyond that in the name of modernization and
nation building.
(For background on this institution and its role in Ingush
society, see especially , “Families and clans
in Ingushetia and Chechnya. A fieldwork report,” Central Asian Survey
24:4 (2005): 453-467 and windowoneurasia2.blogspot.com/2018/12/ingush-teip-council-assumes-ever-larger.html).
When the popular protests against the border accord
began, the leaders of the teips came out in support of those who had taken to
the streets to defend the lands of their ancestors. Indeed, many of those
demonstrating argued that they had to defend the lands in question because they
were the homes and graves of their ancestors or teips.
But as sometimes happens when a group re-emerges for one
reason, it will expand to take on additional roles. That is happening with the
teips in Ingushetia, who have now taken up the cudgels against the Yevkurov
regime, its corruption and its illegal actions, and is pressing its case by
letters to the authorities and the use of the Internet to spread the word.
For an example of this, see fortanga.org/2019/02/obrashhenie-soveta-tejpov-o-davlenii-ingushskih-vlastej-na-protivnikov-soglasheniya-po-granitse/ (video)
and zamanho.com/?p=3524
and zamanho.com/?p=3573
(text).
The re-emergence
of the teips as a political force almost certainly will only add to the regrets
some officials around Yevkurov and in Moscow may already be experiencing as a
result of the border accord because it means that in that region, the most
traditional element of Ingush society has now been energized and set in motion,
a force the powers will find it hard to contain.
No comments:
Post a Comment