Paul
Goble
Staunton, November 2 – In his
classic novel, “A Day Longer than an Age,” the Kyrgyz writer Chingiz Aitmatov
offered the powerful image of “mankurts,” people deprived of their identities and thus
transformed into more pliant and subservient slaves of others. And this image
was applied by many to the peoples of Central Asia in the late Soviet period.
But now, the notion that large
numbers of a nation in the Russian Federation have been deprived of their
identities has been extended to the ethnic Russians themselves by Veniamin
Bashlachev who argues that this is a cancer that threatens to destroy the
Russian nation in the near future (svpressa.ru/blogs/article/102767/).
He lays the blame for this on three
things: the Bolshevik insistence that Russians must compensate for their
earlier rule by promoting the identities of other nations, the failure of
Soviet and Russian leaders to come down hard on those non-Russians who killed
Russians, and the work of now mass media which don’t discuss the state of
Russian self-consciousness.
The first and second of these
factors, he says, have contributed to the sense among non-Russians in the
former Soviet space that they can oppress or even kill Russians with impunity,
an idea that spread from relatively small pogroms against Russians in various
places at the end of Soviet times to Chechnya and now to Ukraine.
But the third appears to be even
more insidious in its impact within Russia where the media is playing the role
of the leather straps on the shaved heads of those Aitmatov said were destined
to be mankurt-slaves for their new masters and second class people for members
of all other groups.
In support of this contention,
Bashlachev offers two pieces of evidence. On the one hand, he says, the failure
of Russians to volunteer for pro-Moscow units in Ukraine in large numbers shows
that the Russian nation does not have the one or two percent of “passionate”
members on whom the survival of any nation depends.
And on the other, he cites the
increasing number of Russians who did not declare any nationality in the last
three censuses. In historically Russian regions, Bashlachev says, the numbers doing
that are still small but they are growing “in geometrical proportion” and thus
point to an ongoing threat of deracination of Russians.
In 1989, he says, a few dozen of every 100,000
residents declared that they had no
nationality; in 2002, the same number did but now among each 1,000 did so; and
in 2010, that figure was true for every 100 residents. And he suggests that in
future censuses, the share of those not identifying as Russians in Russian
regions will only increase.
(That ever more Russians even in
Russian regions are not declaring themselves to be Russians is true, but the figures
he offers are very much exaggerated and reflect other trends as well, including
the rise of other sub-ethnic identities like Siberians or Cossacks and a
turning away from ethnic identity as such.)
Bashlachev says that people in
Russian regions are not being deprived of their memories and identities as the
medieval mankurts were but with modern methods: “They are now losing their
memory with the help of the mass media,” which leads some to say that they are “ashamed”
of being Russian. That is often the first step to the loss of identity.
And with the loss of identity, he
continues, there is a loss of demographic vitality. The overall population of
Russia may now again be increasing slightly, but in historically Russian
regions, it is continuing to decline because “there is a direct connection
between the wounding of Russian self-consciousness and the withering away of
the Russian people.”
Bashlachev concludes: “In real life,
self-consciousness is the most important and root quality of an individual. It
is ‘the cement’ which ties separate individuals into a people.
Self-consciousness is a defense mechanism which allows a people to reliably
stand up to the challenges of the surrounding world.”
In short, “without
self-consciousness,” he warns, “a people as a subject of history disappears.”
No comments:
Post a Comment