Paul
Goble
Staunton, May 7 – Many have been
struck by Belarusian leader Alyaksandr Lukashenka’s decision to go ahead with
the Victory Day parade despite the coronavirus even though Vladimir Putin has postponed
the Moscow one because of the pandemic and even speculated that Lukashenka is
trying to embarrass his Russian counterpart.
There may be something in that, of
course, Ukrainian commentator Vitaly Portnikov says; but the real reason is
deeper: Lukashenka is a survival of the past, whose contempt for human life is typical
of his Soviet predecessors and whose society is not yet in a position to demand
that he behave differently (graniru.org/opinion/portnikov/m.278845.html).
Putin while he might like to behave
in the same way faces a different situation because Russian society not only
has changed but is stronger, Portnikov says. He “can permit himself much but
not a defiant neglect of the lives of Russians.” The response of the population to that,
especially in the current circumstances, could be politically fatal.
By his refusal to take steps to
protect the Belarusian people from the pandemic and his decision to go ahead
with the parade, Lukashenka has shown himself to be “the direct heir of the
Soviet elites, the very same who stopped German tanks with the bodies of Soviet
soldiers or held May Day parades after Chernobyl,” the commentator continues.
“In the Soviet Union, the value of
human life was reduced to nothing; and of course, no Central Committee general
secretary would ever cancel a parade or demonstration because of some invisible
coronavirus even if he had known that as a result, whole cities would perish,”
Portnikov says.
“Celebratory meetings, parades, and
demonstrations, all that ritual which copied church rites, gave meaning to the
existence of communist meaninglessness.” And that is because however absurd
they appeared to outsiders, the chief meaning of these events was “marching
before the leader” and reaffirming his power.
According to Portnikov, “in this
sense, Lukashenka really gets the prize of honor in the form of a parade and
receives a patent for the further killing of Belarusians. But of course, more
interesting is the question: why is he holding a parade while Putin is not?”
However paradoxical it may soon, the
reason lies “not in the dictators themselves” but rather in the contrasting
experiences of the two countries in the 1990s, the cursed 1990s that Russia
passed through but that Belarus thanks to the Sovietism of Lukashenka did not,
Portnikov says.
The experiences of that decade in
Russia “set new ‘red lines’ concerning the value of human life in the
understanding of the leadership and began the process, now being broken by the
behavior of Putin, to cure society from Stalinism.” Russians came to understand
that a May Day parade at the time of Chernobyl was “a crime not some heroic
act.”
As a result, Russians reacted
differently than they had earlier, horrified by the human losses with the sinking
of the Kursk or the tragedies at Budennovsk, Dubrovka and Beslan. And the Kremlin
had to hide the truth about the losses from Putin’s wars in Ukraine, Syria and
elsewhere.
Consequently, Lukashenka and not yet
Putin is “today the best student of the cannibal [Stalin] who greeted the participants
of the first Victory Parade and never reflected about the price of their
victories.”
No comments:
Post a Comment