Thursday, November 19, 2026

Soviet Identity Remains in Place and Continues to Shape Russian Thinking, Savvin Says

Paul Goble

            Staunton, Nov. 14 – Russians may have turned away from communism but their minds remain shaped by the power of the Soviet identity Moscow imposed on them when the Soviet Union existed, an identity that reflects the compromises the communists made in a largely modernized country on which they imposed totalitarianism, Dmitry Savvin says.

            The editor of the Riga-based conservative Russian Harbin portal discusses how and why this identity was created and why it remains, but perhaps the most important portion of his article is a list of 14 characteristics of this Soviet-er mentality that he argues remains in place (harbin.lv/sovetskaya-identichnost-sverkhkratkiy-ocherk). These include:

1.     “State power is perceived as transcendentally given, an elemental force beyond human influence” with a “sacred” status.

2.     This power is “personified in ‘an ideal hero,’” the founder or current ruler of the country.

3.     “Concepts such ‘the Motherland’” refer exclusively to the state and patriotism is “defined exclusively as loyalty” to the powers that be.

4.     This identity is characterized by “a near-total absence of civic consciousness or civic self-organization” and “a fundamental lack of understanding what these concepts are or why they might be necessary.”

5.     This view is supported by “extreme social atomization which exists alongside a proclaimed ethos of ‘collectivization’ or ‘communalism.’”

6.     Such identities lead the population to expect that the state itself “must be strong and regulate every sphere of social life.”

7.     Those holding this view see private property not as something sacred but something that should and is viewed with suspicion.

8.     “Nationally based culture is completely replaced by mass culture.”.

9.     That is sometimes obscured by the fact that an extreme form of xenophobia is cultivated and expected.

10.  Indifference toward religion is cultivated and combined with “the most primitive superstitions.”

11.  Such identities feature “a low level of ethnic solidarity” and preference for thinking of the country as a whole.

12.  This Soviet survival includes “ignorance and misunderstanding of European political culture” and arrangements like the separation of power.

13.  This ignorance is combined with “a deep knowledge of the true mechanisms of the function of this system which are perceived as normal and even eternal.”

14.  And that combination produces legal nihilism with the only acceptable form of resistance to power is either “corruption” or “self-isolation.”

No comments:

Post a Comment