Sunday, August 2, 2020

As Protests Enter Third Week, Khabarovsk Residents Now Say ‘We are the Power Here!’


Paul Goble

            Staunton, July 31 – As the demonstrations in Khabarovsk which began as a protest against Moscow’s removal of the elected governor of that region enter their third week, they have changed not only their demands but how those making them view themseleves. Today, Khabarovsk people proudly declare that, whatever Moscow thinks, “we are the power here.” 

            That psychological transformation is hard to measure and even describe in detail, but such shifts as the events in some republics at the end of the Soviet period show are the ones on which future developments are likely to be driven (znak.com/2020-07-31/zhiteli_habarovska_tri_nedeli_vyhodyat_na_stihiynye_mitingi_i_shestviya).

            Khabarovsk residents were angered by Putin’s decision to remove Sergey Furgal and then further infuriated by the Kremlin leader’s decision to impose on them someone who was part of the same political party (the LDPR) but not one of their own chosen by election. And this anger has been further exacerbated by official actions since that time.

            The Kremlin-appointed head, Mikhail Degtyarev, has made it worse for himself and the regime by suggesting that outside agitators are behind the protests rather than showing that he understands that the people in the street are the people of Khabarovsk who now feel empowered to speak up for themselves.

            Degtyarov’s regime has detained a blogger, prompted the driver of the Furgalmobile to declare a hunger strike, and begun to arrest and fine individuals for taking part in the protests. But instead of intimidating the people of Khabarovsk, such actions have only made the population angrier and more ready to protest.

            And statements by Khabarovsk officials that people should not take children to the protests because of the risk of “psychological trauma” or coronavirus infection or warnings that no one should risk taking part in such “unsanctioned actions” have proven equally counter-productive.

            The people of Khabarovsk are more committed than ever to the defense of their rights to choose their own leader rather than have to live under one imposed by the Kremlin and they are encouraged by the fact that people in other Far Eastern cities are backing them and that polls show almost half of all Russians support their aspirations. Only 17 percent oppose them.

            Unfortunately and pointing to a crisis at some point in the future, among those 17 percent are the denizens of the Putin dictatorship.

Uzbek Traditions Continue to Restrict Women’s Roles to Family Alone, Khalikova Says


Paul Goble

            Staunton, July 31 – Women can play a key even transforming role in traditional societies, as the Bolsheviks recognized and as the late Gregory Massell documented in his 1974 study, The Surrogate Proletariat: Moslem Women and Revolutionary Strategies in Soviet Central Asia, 1919-1929 (Princeton, 1974).

            But in the absence of government efforts to emancipate women, traditions in Uzbekistan and elsewhere in Central Asia remain so strong that women continue to be forced to subordinate their activities to those of their parents, brothers and husbands and thus are deprived of a chance to realize their own goals, Nodira Khalikova says.

             From the moment they are born, Uzbek women are raised to support others rather than promote themselves, the Uzbek commentator says; and while they are pleased to do the former, many feel more than a little bitterness that they are not allowed to pursue their own goals and be helped in that regard (hook.report/2020/07/glavnoye-prabilno-vospitat/).

            “As a result of traditions,” Khalikova writes, “we are preparing our children for life in an Uzbek society” in such a way that gender roles “are predetermined. From their earliest years, we teach our daughters that it is absolutely normal to neglect one’s own interests in order to help mother in the kitchen or prepare meals for a brother.”

            As they grow up, Uzbek girls come to assume that there is no other way. They are forced to marry early, before 25 at the latest lest they be viewed as “old maids” when they are 28 or 30.  And they are told to defer to their mothers and then their husbands no matter how they are treated and what they want because tradition and the family require it.
           
            What is striking and unfortunate is that no one ever tells Uzbek boys the same thing. They are told to pursue their dreams and that their wives and daughters will do everything to support them, even to the point of giving up on their rights and aspirations as individuals, the commentator continues.

            The government reinforces this now with schools offering courses like “The Sense of the Homeland” which elevate the family to the key building block of the state and make women responsible for holding it together regardless of their interests and regardless of how they are treated by their husbands and his relatives.

            In her classic book, The Second Sex, Simone de Beauvoir observed that “women are not born: they are raised to be what they are.”  In Uzbekistan, they are being raised to be servants of their families and husbands rather than to be independent individuals.  And that is a tragedy for them and for Uzbek society as a whole.

            Indeed, Khalikova says, any society that tells girls and women that being able to cook is more important than having the chance to read books is sending the wrong message and one that holds both women and the society back. But that is exactly what Uzbek families and the Uzbek state are doing to this day.

            Uzbekistan has many strong women who could accomplish so much more if they weren’t constantly being told that they must focus on the family and defer to their husbands and children even if that means that they have to give up any chance of achieving their own goals, she concludes. 

Pandemic has Forced 30 Percent of Russians to Work at Home or Seek New Employment


Paul Goble

            Staunton, July 31 – Despite the pandemic and quarantine, 70 percent of Russians say they continue to work in the same way at the same place; only 30 percent indicate that they have had to work at home or seek new positions because they have lost old ones, a Levada Center survey reports (levada.ru/2020/07/31/koronavirus-strah-i-zanyatost/).

            Thus, the dislocations and changes many have talked about while large have hardly been as all-embracing as some coverage has suggested.  And that in turn means that the impact of the coronavirus on patterns of employment and the underlying structure of the economy is likely to be less than many have suggested.

            The pandemic nonetheless continues. Russian officials reported that they had registered 5482 new cases of infection bringing that total to 839,981 and 161 new deaths, upping that total to 161 (t.me/COVID2019_official/1171). In some places, where the numbers had been trending down, including Moscow, they are now rising again (regnum.ru/news/3025346.html).

            In others, such as Chechnya, the new figures have jumped (regnum.ru/news/3025582.html), while in a third group of regions, they have continued as much the same level or declined. One more senior official, Yamal head Dmitry Artyulkhov reportedly has fallen ill with the coronavirus (regnum.ru/news/3025250.html).

            Openings and re-closings have followed these trends. To give but one of dozens of examples, officials in Tyva, officials said that the threat is so great that wearing masks and observing social distance and sanitary rules “must become the new norm of life” (regnum.ru/news/3024890.html).

            Russian Railways announced it was restoring the operation of 180 runs that had been stopped earlier (regnum.ru/news/3025542.html), and airlines, which have announced the restoration of international flights, are as yet finding it difficult to meet the schedules they have announced (lenta.ru/news/2020/07/31/otmena/).

            At the same time, Russian consumer affairs officials are telling people to be careful in planning foreign trips and to check schedules several days in advance of departure because unexpected changes are still quite possible (regnum.ru/news/3025335.html).

            Economic news remains dire. Economists say the real decline in Russian incomes may be twice what the government is saying (krizis-kopilka.ru/archives/78687) and add Moscow is trying to make the situation appear better than it is by citing growth from the bottom of the decline rather than comparing figures now with those before the pandemic (krizis-kopilka.ru/archives/78692).


            And especially infuriating in this regard is a report in Izvestiya that prices for domestically produced medications have soared 23.8 percent since the pandemic began while imported drugs have gone up only 7.5 percent (iz.ru/1042068/anna-ivushkina/tcennyi-sbor-vyruchka-aptek-v-pervom-polugodii-vyrosla-na-14).

            Meanwhile, in other pandemic-related developments in Russia today,

·         Since the pandemic began, Russians have been buying more life insurance policies (regnum.ru/news/3025082.html).

·         Cancer patients are finding it harder to get chemotherapy because hospitals have refocused on treating those with coronavirus infections (idelreal.org/a/30756949.html).

·         Moscow officials report that they have fined more than 6,000 firms a total or more than 300 million rubles (4.8 million US dollars) for failing to require masks be worn by sales personnel and customers (https://tass.ru/moskva/9091935).