Paul
Goble
Staunton, February 7 – Today, on the
Day of Russian Science, the Accounting Chamber released data showing that
Russia spends far less than other countries on scientific research – it devotes
only 1.1 percent of its GDP to that effort, far less than Israel which spend
4.25 percent or China which spends 2.12 percent.
It ranks 34th on this
measure among the countries of the world, and its achievements reflect its
spending, the Chamber said: Chinese scholars submitted 38 times more patent
applications last year than did Russia’s (mk.ru/science/2020/02/07/obnarodovany-dannye-o-toksichnykh-problemakh-rossiyskoy-nauki.html).
Russia
has a very large number of people working in scientific research. In terms of
that measure, it ranks fourth, behind only China, the US and Japan. But they
are far less productive: Russia does not rank even in the to 20 countries in
terms of publications in the most read and cited scientific journals.
One
of the major reasons for this are problems arising from the state’s dominant
role: In China, for example, the state provides only 20 percent of the funds
needed for research while businesses provide most of the rest. In Russia,
however, the government is responsible for 66.2 percent of such funding, the Accounting
Chamber says.
Domestic
businesses are responsible for only 30 percent of the money spent on research
in Russia. The reason they don’t is that while Russian scholars are able to
come up with new ideas, they are seldom inclined to develop them to the point
that they can be introduced directly into production, thus making businesses
skeptical of the value of putting money into this sector.
Government-supplied
research funding is often allocated ineffectively, the Chamber says, with money
given to projects not on the basis of expert review but rather for other less
defensible reasons. As a result, what money Moscow does spend doesn’t produce
the results that similar investments do elsewhere.
Moreover,
the government requires so much paper reporting about money given to it that
scholars often are put off just by that or find themselves doing reporting
rather than doing basic research. And
the money the government does spend doesn’t translate into higher salaries:
Russian scientists make much less than those in Europe.
Consequently,
very few young Russians are going into science – certainly not more than one
percent of university graduates – and those who are already scientists are
often seeking to go abroad for higher salaries and greater respect and
opportunities to do what they hoped to do in their fields.
According
to the Accounting Chamber, the Russian government doesn’t provide the
incentives for scientific research that are needed for success and as a result
Russian science is doing increasingly poorly. “And this is logical because scientists
are people just like all others,” Yuliy Kalinina of Moskovsky komsomolets
says in her article on the Chamber’s findings.
Enthusiasm
works for only so long, she continues, and “other stimuli – money, recognition
and authority – are needed.” When those are absent, the entire system slows
down and ultimately fails. Some suggest
that holding a gun to the heads of scientists and making them work is a
solution.
But
one doesn’t want to contemplate that option, Kalinina says, especially on the
Day of Russian Science.
No comments:
Post a Comment