Paul Goble
Staunton,
October 9 – Almost every day brings a new case of official incompetence, Ivan
Davydov says, a display of the inability of officials to do their job and of
their simultaneous insistence that they are competent and that others to get
ahead should follow in their footsteps, a pattern that will produce more
failures but ultimately alienate Russians from their leaders.
The Moscow
commentator says that it is now impossible to know “who began this wild parade
of incompetence.” Was it the failure of
officials in Vladivostok to carry out their falsification of elections in a way
that not everyone would see? Or was it one official challenging Aleksey Navalny
to a duel? (mbk.sobchakprotivvseh.ru/sences/s-chego-nachinaetsy/).
Or was it the story, pushed by government
media, that American astronauts had worked to destroy a Russian spacecraft? Or
was it the Salisbury poisonings which highlighted the incompetence of Russia’s
secret services? The answer doesn’t
really matter because all these stories point to “the total and catastrophic
incompetence of people related to the powers that be.”
And tragically this incompetence is
spreading down into the population because the state is organizing things like
a cardboard Reichstag for children to storm or teachers who recognize that the
only way to prepare their charges for success is to encourage them to be like
the incompetents who are in charge.
A recent poll of Russian teachers found
that they respected among politicians, Putin, Lavrov, Zhirinovsky, Glazyev, and
Kadyrov; among cultural figures, Mikhalkov, Kobzon, and Loza. No, seriously,
Yury Loza; and among journalists, Pozner, Solovyev and for some reason Gordon.
And so on.”
One would like to believe that this isn’t
typical and that the majority of teachers are in fact “normal people.” It
simply can’t be that “good teachers have disappeared completely.” But if there are, their work undoubtedly is “corrected”
by the propaganda of the state and by its displays of official incompetence.
The entire system, Davydov continues, is
now all about producing “failures so that there will be replacements if the
current failures aren’t able to destroy everything in their own time.”
But what is especially remarkable about
all this, he says, is that those who lived through the last years of the Soviet
Union know that young people and others will ultimately prefer real life to the
mythology the state puts about especially when the state demonstrates at each
step that it is incompetent and cannot manage the simplest things.
That preference, of course, led them not
only to understand the failures of those above them but also to take part in “’the
greatest geopolitical catastrophe’” of the 20th century. Given that it is nearly certain that “today’s
children are no more stupid than we were then,” they certainly understand too –
and they will repeat this drama, getting rid of trash and incompetence in the
name of life itself.
No comments:
Post a Comment