Paul
Goble
Staunton, February 4 – A proposal by
Federation Council member Zhanna Ivanova to restore a nationality line in
Russian passports has sparked concern among many who remember how such a line
was used against Jews in Soviet times, worries that it may become a test of
loyalty under Putin, and amusement about how Russians might in fact fill it out
now.
Ivanova has called for a new law
that would allow Russian citizens to indicate their ethnic nationality in their
passports, something she says will guarantee “the preservation of the
uniqueness of each national (ethnic) community of the multi-national people of
the Russian Federation” (asozd2.duma.gov.ru/main.nsf/(Spravka)?OpenAgent&RN=713185-6).
According to the
draft legislation, those who want to declare their nationality will have to pay
a premium, will have the right to change their nationality or drop any
reference to it by filing a written declaration, or can have their nationality
defined at birth by their parents. And some deputies, including the KPRF, want
to add a line for “religious affiliation” as well.
One writer old enough to remember Soviet times is
concerned that this measure, offered in the name of supporting ethnic
identities and traditions, might be once again used as it was then most often
against Jews as the basis for discrimination against this or that group,
including ethnic Russians in non-Russian areas (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=54D1CA51EEB2A).
A second commentator is fearful that
when Ivanova talks about nationality, she is in fact thinking about loyalty;
and that in turn will mean that some people will be forced to identify as
members of one nationality when they feel themselves to be members of another
in order to show that they are loyal to the state (echo.msk.ru/blog/y_kanner/1486248-echo/).
And
a third suggests that in the current environment officials are going to
discover that people will declare all kinds of things as nationalities that the
officials won’t be happy about just as they have objected when people
identified their nationality in the census as Cossack or Siberian (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=54D0E5A85C087).
Yevgeny Ikhlov gives one possible
scenario: A 14-year-old comes in to get a passport. Asked his nationality, he
responds “I don’t know. My mommy is a hobbit, and my old man is a pure ork!” One can only imagine what the officials will
do with that.
While Ivanova’s proposal may not go
anywhere, it will divide both Russians and non-Russians and thus exacerbate the
Russian Federation’s always sensitive ethnic issue. On the one hand, it will
undermine the chance Moscow will be able to successfully introduce a non-ethnic
Russian identity, something the regime has been trying to do for almost two
decades.
And on the other, it will
simultaneously help some small groups to survive while giving added incentive
to Russian officials to promote the re-identification of members of such groups
as Russians in the name of integration and political loyalty. A better way to
anger members of both sides would be difficult to imagine.
No comments:
Post a Comment