Paul Goble
Staunton,
June 28 – Perhaps because of the role food shortages have played in sparking
revolutions and revolts in Russia, some Moscow commentators have suggested that
Turkmenistan is now on the brink of a rebellion against the repressive regime
in Ashgabat because of rising food shortages there (ng.ru/cis/2018-06-28/6_7254_rebellion.html).
But Atadzhan Nepesov, an analyst for
the Fergana News Agency, says that while there are serious problems with the
supply of food in that Central Asian country, they may not be as dire as some
are reporting and that in any case, they are unlikely on their own to trigger any
revolt or revolution (fergananews.com/articles/10035).
In Turkmenistan, harvests begin on
dates set by the president rather than by the weather or the ripeness of the
crops; and they are invariably accompanied by upbeat stories about how
wonderful the harvest is and how there is a super-abundance of food for the
population, Nepesov says.
At the same time, he continues, foreign
and thus independent news services have been reporting food shortages, long lines,
and growing popular anger not only in the regions but in the capital that some
have seen as the basis for a rebellion (Cf.
windowoneurasia2.blogspot.com/2018/03/hunger-spreads-in-turkmenistan.html
and windowoneurasia2.blogspot.com/2018/03/food-riots-in-turkmenistan-have-now.html).
The truth, Nepesov
continues, is somewhere in between. Because foreign news sites are blocked in
Turkmenistan and because the local population doesn’t trust the government’s
reports, rumors start and spread, with events often magnified or distorted in
the process, leading to false conclusions.
It is absolutely true that people
have been standing in line to buy food but less because of shortages than
because of fears of a general rise in prices. Better to buy now than to wait
and have to pay more in the future. That has led to shortages, but they are
driven primarily by actions of this kind rather than a general shortfall in the
delivery of basic foodstuffs.
And even when government stores run
short, there are still the bazaars where for somewhat higher prices, food is
available. If that were to change, then
the situation could easily get out of hand. Nepesov doesn’t say; but from his
words it appears that the bazaars in Turkmenistan are today playing the role
that private plots did in the USSR a generation ago.
A major reason that Turkmens believe
the rumors that there will be price rises is that Ashgabat, to please the
president and boost his international image, has been celebrating the country’s
role as a food exporter, even though they know that last year the harvest was
almost a third less than normal. That is a real source of anger.
But Nepesov says that the situation
is nowhere near where it was in the 1990s. Then there were real food shortages,
rationing was introduced, the population protested by blocking roads, and
officials fled from some villages and towns in fear for their lives. Turkmens remember this – and so too does the
government.
“Today’s ‘bread crisis’ in terms of
its potential to spark protests is incomparably smaller than was the situation
that exited 20 to 25 years ago,” Nepesov says. “However, the situation all the
same remains a matter of concern” and has been made worse by the government’s
own propagandistic actions.
According to a retired official of
the Turkmenistan state statistical agency who was a military buddy of Nepesov’s
and who spoke on condition of anonymity, official figures on foodstuffs and
exports are simply made up. “It is
completely possible,” he says, that in running after the image of ‘a world
exporter of grain,’ our president has allowed more grain to be sold on the
foreign market than the real situation in the country allows.”
“And today we are reaping the fruits
of this race after cheap populism,” he continues, suggesting that the real
threat to the Turkmenistan leader and his regime is not that there isn’t enough
food but that Ashgabat’s lies about the situation are sapping what’s left of
popular tolerance for it.
Consequently, there may not be a food
rebellion in Turkmenistan in the next months; but there is no reason for the
government there to think that the situation is such that it will remain
forever stable.
No comments:
Post a Comment