Paul
Goble
Staunton, August 31 – Many, from the
leaders of Western countries to the leaders of the Russian opposition, are
failing to recognize that a bandit can play the role of a businessman, an
official or “even the president of a nuclear power,” but that whatever role he
is in, he nonetheless remains a bandit, Pavel Shekhtman says.
They must realize that “if something
acts like a dog, it is a dog” and that “bandit isn’t a course word, it is
simply the name of a profession, which,
like any other profession – bookkeeper, military officer, or prostitute –
leaves its mark on the outlook and mentality of an individual,” the Moscow
commentator says (kasparov.ru/material.php?id=59A588D2BF8B4).
And this, rather
than the nominal position “is the defining factor: everything else is
secondary.”
“A bandit may turn up in the role of
businessman (the majority of bandits are nominally that), a bureaucrat, a
policeman, a judge or even the president of a nuclear power. None of these other positions means that he
ceases to be a bandit, and consequently for achieving results in dealing with
them one must adopt methods” used to deal with criminals.
Unfortunately, Shekhtman says, “this
is something that neither Obama nor Nemtsov wants to understand.
He continues: “In the struggle with
a bandit, one can appeal only to force. Even when you appeal to legal
institutions, you all the same are appealing to force, to the state apparatus of
force which by definition is stronger than any band. Law doesn’t work by itself – law works
through a complex system where behind the judge always stands the policeman …
and the jailor.”
But there are circumstances when
there is no such force behind the law because the bandits have taken over that
as well. This is the case in Russia now, and the only real possibility of
salvation is to create “the appearance” of such legality so that the bandits
will decide that it is better to adapt to that than to continue as they are.
“Naturally, this is a very risky
method of struggle, but it is the only possible one from a position of weakness”
which is where those in Russia are given the current power of the bandits there
at the top. Those “who don’t play poker with the bandits is [will otherwise]
simply be giving everything away.”
No comments:
Post a Comment